Comments | nin_icontest: PICK MY BEST voting!

utrose_graphics in nin_icontest

PICK MY BEST voting!

Dec 17, 2007 14:13

PLEASE PAY ATTENTION TO THE VOTING RULES, PLACES, ETC! THIS IS A SPECIAL CONTEST SO THERE ARE SPECIAL RULES!

Places
- Each Set will have a 1st Place Icon
- There will be a "Best Set" Place
- AFTER VOTING IS COMPLETED; The First Place Icons from each set will then be voted on in a second round determining the "best" Overall Icon

Rules- You can ( Read more... )

voting

Comments 6

anonymous December 17 2007, 20:33:52 UTC

utrose_graphics December 17 2007, 20:51:26 UTC

Heh, thank you for voting, but if I could get you to give a comment for why you chose each icon, and the set, that would be great! Just because everyone likes hearing what they're doing right, you know? :)

~Beth

anonymous December 18 2007, 03:29:06 UTC

*cough* *mod hat* utrose_graphics December 18 2007, 04:06:52 UTC

Could I possibly get you to read the RULES before voting? There is a sample vote. Please use it and change the appropriate parts (add your own reasons for the icons/set you chose, etc.) and revote when you have done so.

Thank you.

~Beth

utrose_graphics December 21 2007, 08:43:18 UTC

- no more votes accepted beyond this post -

Icon voting results. utrose_graphics December 21 2007, 09:06:13 UTC

1A (because the cropping and use of greyscale works well
1A (Because I like the crop and add of colour.)
1A (I like it because the crop is original.)
1B (I'm quite partial to the layering on this icon.)
1B (The colours and textures are appealing to my taste)
1B, because it looks very simple, even though it's obviously layered, and I like the crop
1B - I like the way the texture was (or were, if there's more than one) used - the slight bit of colour on an otherwise black and white icon is beautiful, and I like the text, even if I can't read it.
1D (The coloured texture in the background is used beautifully)
1D (I like the lens flare and the sharp image.)
1E - I like the colors, the shadows, and the pic choice.

2A (I really like the placing of the text
2A - The text placement makes the whole icon.
2B (Because of the crop and subtleness of colour.)
2C (Le neck porn!)
2E, because it's gorgeous - does that count? I just really, really, really love the colouring here ( ... )

Icon voting results (cont.). utrose_graphics December 21 2007, 09:07:39 UTC

4A, I like the way the lyrics are blending in / fading out, and I like the blue
4A (Very nice use of textures and text)
4A (Good use of text and contrast)
4A (I like the text, the picture used and the blue colouring - the way the icon was laid out is just extremely appealing.)
4D (It stands out because of the green grass.)
4D (The colouring)
4D - The image is amusing and the text well done. Green is good.
4D - It's a nice, vibrant icon that really fits the text that was used. Brilliant.
4D (I like the use of colour and text.)
4D (I like the fresh colouring.)

5A - This one's mine. :)
5B (I like the evil feeling of the icon - the way it's cropped, the colouring and the text (especially the bolded parts) all contribute to that, and it works great ( ... )