Comments | ninjaalexa: I changed my mind!

ninjaalexa

I changed my mind!

Jul 17, 2005 22:42

ok, ok, ok, OK. I've calmed down now, read it twice, and I'm going to rationally think about this snape thing. Here is my theory....

I think that Snape isn't really a traitor, I think that Dumbledore made snape promise to do whatever it took to stay a spy to voldermort, just like he made Harry promise to do whatever he said. I think this because

1 ( Read more... )

Comments 8

It's must be fate! radichio July 18 2005, 04:16:15 UTC

Oh, God! We ARE soulmates. I've got anything and everything I have available crossed that Snape is not, in fact, a traitor. And if he is, he better kick some Voldemort ass and take the title Dark Lord. And from this throne he can sow some royal seed.

Heres to hoping, anyway.

And you should have posted a spoiler warning somewhere! People will totally harp at you about spoiling the book for them.

Re: It's must be fate! ninjaalexa July 18 2005, 06:20:44 UTC

snape on a sexy throne...yeah I like it alot! With long black robes and a sexy, sexy little crown....mmm..sorry! I'm back.

amen to the hope sister friend. And as far as spoiling, I figure any big get mad at spoilers fan will have read it by now, especially if they read my journal, but sorry if I did do that to anyone!

Re: It must be fate! radichio July 18 2005, 15:51:15 UTC

I just read that. "Sevey?" What in God's name are you thinking? You don't butcher a name like Severus (Shiver.) into a nickname. Snape obviously showed great disdain for nicknames after Harry said his was "Roonil Wazlib"; respect that!

I thank Heaven for the fact that, no matter how obscure, Snape-who-hates-nicknames is now canon. Nyah!

Please ignore that typo in my first title. I fixed it in this one.

Hey, look! My icon's nipples are off!

roxisax July 18 2005, 04:29:00 UTC

i like your theories.
i told alaina i wasn't convinced snape was bad, i just couldn't justify my thought process, seeing as the recent events point to his undeniable evil-ness...
**love**

ninjaalexa July 18 2005, 06:21:26 UTC

i like my theories too, just cause I want to believe snape is good so I can keep my little fantasy.
*LOVE TO YOU!*

surrenderdataco July 18 2005, 06:15:28 UTC

I wish you were right, I hope you are. But it all seems so impossible. I mean, if snape was loyal then dumbledore would have known about the plot right?

ninjaalexa July 18 2005, 06:22:30 UTC

NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! and NO!

remember cause in the book Draco wouldn't tell snape his plan, even though snape wanted to know so bad. See? He wanted to know so he could tell Dumbledore! I'M RIGHT I SAY! RIGHT!!!!!!!

m34n54r4h July 22 2005, 01:12:45 UTC

i love the hell out of you (both of you)!!!! your points were exactly right i think!!! and everyone knows what i think is the most important right?.......anyway but yes, hell yes, AND fuck yes, to all you said!!!!

yes...

Snape.......*drool*........god damn its not fair!!!!