Comments | noblerot: Deathly Hallows: Now With Sappy Rott.

noblerot

Deathly Hallows: Now With Sappy Rott.

Jul 22, 2007 00:41

fyrie just pointed out, on another journal, a vital something I overlooked.

( SPOILERZ )

Comments 19

la_sonnambula July 22 2007, 08:29:06 UTC

My hat is cynical and my heart black, so when I see that I think,

Harry Potter: No wonder we always do it missionary style!

noblerot July 22 2007, 08:35:38 UTC

You're right. It's not just sad, it's SEXX.

la_sonnambula July 22 2007, 08:55:46 UTC

Oh and back to the names. A Malfoy would never give a lame ass name like Scorpius.

noblerot July 22 2007, 09:01:49 UTC

Yeah, Scorpius stretches my credulity to the snapping point. But AS/S is made of win.

Thread 6

scarah2 July 22 2007, 08:34:30 UTC

Didn't you think that was kinda gross?

noblerot July 22 2007, 08:37:29 UTC

What, like an aging man's perverse transference of sexual desire from dead mother to teenage son? Sounds fine to me.

scarah2 July 22 2007, 08:43:48 UTC

I keep loling every time I picture them having to make this movie.

Rickman: Look... at... me...
DanRad: *SNORT*

They seriously need a bloopers reel.

noblerot July 22 2007, 09:05:22 UTC

I think the character breaks will start when Harry has to fondle Draco's wand. It'll be downhill from there, and before you know it, they'll be blinding the thestrals.

Thread 9

fictionbya July 22 2007, 09:38:23 UTC

I WAS EXPECTING HIM TO DIE IN A REALLY OVER THE TOP WAY. Got the rug yanked out under me on that one. It was so brief and sad.

_hannelore July 22 2007, 16:10:37 UTC

*hugz* When I first heard the spoiler from JKR that Snape had been loved by someone, I remember fearing what was going to come of that. But the more I think about it, I'm imagining Snape as completely smitten by this pretty, pretty girl who (lo and behold) actually cares for him as well. I don't find it tender and schmoopy, I find there's a lot of room for angst and woe. And Snape is selfish, just as selfish as Dumbledore, for his wish to have Lily's life be spared.

Snape could have certainly took his secrets to the grave, but he gave them to Harry. More than that, Harry doesn't seem disgusted or freaked out by the fact that Snape loved his mother, he accepts it.

dementedsiren July 23 2007, 16:53:15 UTC

More than that, Harry doesn't seem disgusted or freaked out by the fact that Snape loved his mother, he accepts it.

Just a random thought on this, but could it be because Harry would always believe anyone could love his mother? She is the one character we see almost no flaws in (with the exception of the some of her interaction with Petunia in the memories), and she's the one person no one has every spoken badly of (except Voldemort and the Dursleys, which probably had the opposite effect). And Harry loves her very deeply (in an idealic way unlike his love for his father, who was grounded by Harry knowing the other Marauders)

Hm.

tinderblast July 23 2007, 14:52:06 UTC

Also, yeah, I read the line but assumed it was something to do with Snape being honest/proving himself - it was only later that I realised, post-pensieve, that he wanted to see that sliver of Lily in Harry. That was sad.