Leave a comment

Comments 10

shurimon March 29 2011, 21:51:59 UTC
I- hmmm. I found this a tad hard to follow, as I don't know the canon, and I believe Maka is one of the main characters of the series, so I'd expect the background to have a bit more meat to it. Her abilities are also not explained very well.

However, again, IDK canon so I'm not sure if this is just a condensed version or if there are things missing.

I'd like to get canon verification before voting; I can send this to Hydok (who plays Kid/Seven).

Reply


felinemystique March 30 2011, 16:43:31 UTC
Man, I could have sworn I'd replied to this. :| I agree, it's a little hard to follow in places. I think I get what she's saying about the abilities and human weapons, but again, it could be written more clearly.

I'd also like canon verification, but this app isn't blowing me away.

Reply


snowburned April 1 2011, 02:45:46 UTC
This seems decent, though not spectacular, to me. Definitely want some canon verification because idk canon at all. I do like the personality section; I feel like I have a sense of who she is from there, but again, it could be inaccurate for all I know.

Reply


bloody_pens April 1 2011, 22:52:47 UTC
Hydok says it checks out; she didn't have any problems with it.

So I'll go ahead and give this one a yes. This app is not bad by any means, but like Jaina and Scath, I'm not blown away by it, either.

Reply


felinemystique April 1 2011, 23:21:26 UTC
I'll vote yes as well, then, since the canon checks out.

I will say that she might want to have a permissions post about that soul-reading thing, especially for our shadier characters--what do y'all think?

Reply

snowburned April 1 2011, 23:23:43 UTC
Yeah, I agree. I was thinking that last night but was apparently too tired to remember to type it. >.

Reply

pompous_today April 2 2011, 23:35:38 UTC
Good point- I'll draft something to add to her acceptance.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up