Comments | nyxfixx: Contrariwise, Part 2

nyxfixx

Contrariwise, Part 2

Jan 25, 2007 21:59

( More soup? )

Comments 45

shadowvalkyrie January 27 2007, 10:35:18 UTC

Easily the funniest HP story I've ever read! The basic idea is good and your characterizations are perfect. I love this whole thing!
And now I know why I never liked borscht (even without the doxies, bat shit and other disgusting ingredients)...
I laughed hardest about Kreacher's and Snape's reactions towards Sirius's changed behavior, but the conversation between Sirius and Molly in the beginning was great as well.
You are a genius!

nyxfixx January 27 2007, 22:57:26 UTC

Easily the funniest HP story I've ever read!

Really? Wow! Thank you so much for saying so! I'm so glad you enjoyed this story and I agree 100% - borscht really is pretty nasty, IMHO!

sambethe January 28 2007, 16:17:41 UTC

Heh! I think I was giggling madly during the making of the borscht. A fun read all the way through. Much enjoyed.

nyxfixx January 28 2007, 20:49:40 UTC

I think I was giggling madly during the making of the borscht.

Like a DO NOT DO IT THIS WAY pamphlet, huh? Glad you enjoyed it and thank you for reading!

arachnethe2 January 29 2007, 22:55:51 UTC

Since my antibiothics also eliminated my English skill, the only thing I can write right now is: I loved this story!

I swear I did!

nyxfixx January 30 2007, 20:43:45 UTC

Hi! I'm glad to know you enjoyed this story, though it's too bad you're needing antibiotics. Hope you feel better soon, and thanks for reading!

misstress_max February 1 2007, 03:14:44 UTC

total and utter love for this fic. will pass around to friends.

nyxfixx February 2 2007, 02:05:08 UTC

Thank you! You are very kind to say and I'm glad to know you liked it!

pharrezychica February 1 2007, 21:11:03 UTC

I *adored* this fic. Funny I was surfing all recs, decided to re-read The Shape Of HisHands on ff.net and while there I came across this story =D
You managed to work everything I love in one fic, adding small bits here and there...

I loved this:
While her back was turned, Harry treated Sirius to a gruesome and very dramatic pantomime of falling on his sword. Sirius responded to the show by pointing to his wand, then to Harry, and then making a slicing motion across his throat. Harry choked on a bite of his apple and shook with suppressed amusement while pressing his hands tightly over his mouth.

I loved seeing Harry and Sirius have a careless, fun relationship. Wish JKR spent more time portraying these moments in Grimmauld Place.
Also loved the end with Harry and Remus. Remus' comment about them thinking alike is spot on =P

But most of all the riot that ensued, capslock!Harry, Snape, and oh boy...Wlaburga and Molly! hahahaha!
Wonderful job, this is going in my favs =D

nyxfixx February 2 2007, 02:10:05 UTC

Ah! I wish JKR could have shown Harry and Sirius having some fun together a little bit more too. Love those two together, and heaven knows, they are both characters who could have used a few more chucks.

Thank you for reading and for your lovely feedback! It's great hearing that you enjoyed the story in so much detail!