The parts in quotes are written on a note with the present.
Atem (AU): A red, black, and gold scarf. "Try not to freeze the building again anytime soon, or I'll have to order one for me. - Zel"
Bakura (AU): An amateurish but fairly decent attempt at drawing Atem and Toshi, and a large bag of cookies. "I'm not the artist Atem is, but just getting you the food seemed like a cop-out. Make sure you share them with her. - Zel"
Bushroot: A bag of fertilizer, with a note saying, "I really, really hope this doesn't turn out to be the plant equivalent of fruitcake or something. - Zel"
Etna: A staff that looks like
this, which is a joke that probably only Zel will get. And also another large bag of cookies, because he can't just get her a gag gift. "From Zel."
Lina: He hasn't bothered trying to figure out what else Lina might want; he's just sent her large amounts of food (mun's choice, I suppose), because it's Lina, and food never seems to upset her much. "From Zel."
Stork: What to get for a green hypochondriac you've never even met? Zel's settled on more cookies. "From your Secret Santa".