"Harbor"

Sep 12, 2010 10:07

Prelio awoke slowly, confused for a moment to see his own image staring back at him from the pool of water in front of him.  The hush and roll of the waves behind him whispered a gentle hymnal, calling him back home.  Sickening, rolling pain closed is eyes for a moment, and he lowered his cheek down to rest on the barnacle-covered rocks.  He lay ( Read more... )

prelio

Leave a comment

Comments 17

Edit vyvyan_wilde October 13 2010, 00:09:23 UTC
Hello, I’m your very tardy second week three editor. I’m sorry for the long wait!

“Prelio awoke slowly, confused for a moment to see his own image staring back at him from the pool of water in front of him.”
-This line repeats “[preposition] him” twice, and the result is kind of awkward. I suggest taking out “at him” and just having it be: “... confused for a moment to see his own image staring back from ...”

“Sickening, rolling pain closed is eyes for a moment,”
-“his”

“His soul, however, instinctively know that this was not a good place to die. “
-“knew”

“Groaning, Prelio opened his eyes and looked around.  Lying several feet in front of him, he was surprised a most unusual object.  Wedged between two crags of rock, it was round, a creature perhaps, and of brilliant coloration.”
-Every sentence in this paragraph starts with a verb. Could you maybe switch it up by rewording one of the sentences?

“Lying several feet in front of him, he was surprised a most unusual object.”-This is an awkward sentence, even ignoring the ( ... )

Reply

Re: Edit oryginal_skin November 4 2010, 02:09:16 UTC
Your corrections are spot on-- thank you so much for that. It's amazing how many things one can unintentionally gloss through when they're in the white heat of writing. :-)

I didn't like this piece at all, even as I finished writing it. It think it begs an awful lot, and while something this unusual should be superbly written, I don't know that I was up to the challenge. It's just too unusual to capture the way I tried to.

I do like how I handled the magic as well. I think that's the gem I should take out of this: Write more stuff like that part.

This edit was extremely helpful, and thank you so much! I'm going to have to think about this for a bit before I tackle another piece.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up