Cultural appropriation, pt. 2

Jun 01, 2006 11:11

Or, in which I make myself extremely unpopular and get flamed through the roof ( Read more... )

race/ethnicity/culture: asian-ness, wiscon, race/ethnicity/culture, great cultural appropriation debate of d

Leave a comment

leadensky June 1 2006, 22:45:53 UTC
Okay, then will you define both "dominant culture" and "looks like"?

Because unless you're going to come out and say "this is what is majority" everyone is going to be looking at their own uniqueness and going "but I'm not majority!".

- hg

Reply

oyceter June 1 2006, 22:54:40 UTC
I would define dominant culture in the US as anyone who looks like they're of European (Eastern Europe included) descent with fairly light colored skin.

I do realize that this is problematic, but as a short definition, that'd be mine.

Reply

*intensely frustrated* leadensky June 1 2006, 23:37:57 UTC
I find this problematic to the point of not being able to continue - or, hell, even enter the discussion.

(I spend my entire life being ordered not to judge other people by the color of their skin, and now it's the most important thing about me? Thank you, no.)

(Maybe tommorrow, after I've cooled off a bit. I do look forward to your comments on what exactly is cultural appropriation.)

- hg

Reply

And that comment would have been... leadensky June 1 2006, 23:38:58 UTC
me. Sorry 'bout that.

- hg

Reply

Re: And that comment would have been... oyceter June 1 2006, 23:41:37 UTC
Yup, got that and replied!

Reply

Re: *intensely frustrated* oyceter June 1 2006, 23:41:09 UTC
I'm very sorry you find it problematic. I do as well, and I'm not saying that it is a fair definition. But I think that that is how many people judge other people, and that while it isn't the most important thing about you, it's something that has been shown to be important societally and culturally.

Again, I'm not arguing that it is a right or a fair definition. But then again, neither is the fact that being born with skin of a different color means that you are treated differently, whether it's having more privileges or less.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up