Leave a comment

Comments 17

chubbypup August 11 2011, 20:02:49 UTC
I love this film and 1 adored this. I read it all with a smile on my face. Thankyou.

Reply

paleom August 11 2011, 20:50:54 UTC
.....and I read your comment with a smile on my face. Thank you for taking the time to say you enjoyed it. Comments are my chocolate. SO glad you enjoyed it

**Grinning**

PMxx

Reply


rissabby August 12 2011, 12:25:07 UTC
I hadn't seen the movie in years and years, and my mind kept going to the Cyrano story so I was afraid for awhile that there might be a tragic ending, but eventually I realized that it was going to be romcom through to the end.

I really enjoyed your depiction of Cameron, probably because I'm not a big Cam fan. I find him a bit bland for the SG universe, so I was greatly amused by your rendition of a wonderfully shallow but well meaning and stupid puppy boy. I hope he's happy in Tahoe, and I actually loved his last letter to Rodney... that he met someone and he doesn't feel sick when he talks to her.

I liked your John too. Especially when he was climbing up to Rodney's attic window, and his other Spider-man type feats.

I'd like to know where that picture of Rodney is from. It looks like season 1. Would you let me know where to find it online? I'm working on a project and that might be the photo that works with it.

Reply

Review paleom August 12 2011, 16:03:33 UTC
Thank you so much for the review. Made me grin. Glad you liked it so much.

I thought I'd just find the image and give you the url but took me ages. Its from the 2003 promo shots but I can't find it anywhere except on Gateworld by putting 'Rodney McKay, 2010' in google image search and then copying image to drive without following link. Hopes that helps.

Thanks again for the review!

Pmxx

Reply


verob2002 August 15 2011, 05:56:42 UTC
Sweet! :)

Reply

Review paleom August 15 2011, 07:27:29 UTC
Thanks for taking the time to post a review. Means a lot. Glad you liked it!

Pmxx

Reply


popkin16 August 19 2011, 11:35:17 UTC
I've only seen bits and pieces of the film, but this was hilarious and amazing :P Cameron and his...simplicity made me laugh out loud, though it makes me sad that Rodney did, in fact, sleep with Cameron. (I'm ferociously protective of my OTP.)

I'm so glad the boys got over everything and managed to get their happy ending. They deserve one :D

Reply

Review paleom August 19 2011, 12:50:35 UTC
THANK YOU!!! So glad you enjoyed it and that it actually made you LOL.

Yeah, I would have rathered Cam didn't make it up there but part of the original and it gives a chance for us to see a heartbroken John which is sad but good coz you get to see it mended later. **grin**

Pmxx

Reply


mckaysmonkey September 7 2011, 20:58:42 UTC
Finally found some time to read this all the way through. Sorry it took me so long hun.

Really loved this. It's been a while since I saw the movie, but as far as I can remember it's a really close fit.

The idea of giving John the scar instead of a long nose works really well. Actually, your John is really adorable, scar and all. I think I might keep him for myself ;-)

Reply

Review paleom September 9 2011, 13:03:01 UTC
LOL. Consider him my gift to you.

Glad you enjoyed it and thanks for taking the time to comment.

Pmxx

Reply


Leave a comment

Up