Leave a comment

Comments 10

hirachelwashere December 17 2009, 11:46:18 UTC
Eliminations:
#03 | the coloring is too much
#01 | again the coloring is too much and a little harsh.

Favorites:
#06 | the coloring is nice, it isnt too much but isnt too little. the cropping is nice.
#07 | the coloring is great, crop is good and has a nice soft feel.

Reply


karinmcr December 17 2009, 11:56:45 UTC
Eliminations:
#03 | I can hardly see Hayley, the texture overshadows her.
#01 | I dislike how the person used the texture.

Favorites:
#04 | Original cropping and stunning coloring.
#01 | I like the simplicity.

Reply


untapdtreasure December 17 2009, 12:58:33 UTC
Eliminations:
#03 | overtexturized so much that it really washes out her face and subtracts from the overall quality of the icon
#01 | the texture used really blurs out her face a little especially around the hair

Favorites:
#08 | the crop really sets this one apart from the rest. and its simple soft coloring
#02 | the soft coloring makes this icon really pretty

Reply


bellaprincess9 December 17 2009, 15:08:08 UTC
Eliminations:
#03 | Reason: I don't know what effect they use but the mist/overlay thing is covering the whole icon and is distracting from the main focal point. Less effects please, at least on the face that are overpowering. It ruins the icon for me.
#08 | Reason: I don't like the cropping. I don't know who the person is by just looking at that part.

Favorites:
#06 | Reason: Nice cropping and coloring. Looks good and simple.
#05 | Reason: Although the icon is on the dark side, I like that it doesn't make the person look too white/pale. A nice balance. Cropping is good as well.

Reply


mccrack December 17 2009, 15:47:22 UTC
Eliminations:
#03 | The texture and too pink coloring washes Hayley out.
#02 | The icon is too plain. The crop does nothing for the corpotions and looks too random. The coloring is also too orange.

Favorites:
#01 | Nice composition. Good coloring, just a bit too sharpened.
#06 | Nice coloring and cropping.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up