Results

[kateshepard]

1+++++

2++

3-----

4.--

5.------

6. + -  = 0

7. ---- +       = -3

Negative (-) votes indicate votes for least quality. Positive (+) indicate votes for favorite.
If you would like to know what they said about your icon then comment here with your icon number
Also if you would like a banner for either mods choice/first or second place then tell me

Comments

[kateshepard]

Would you like to know what they said about your icon?

[gingey123]

Don't worry! It wasn't a great icon, I'll admit I struggled :) I'll definitely be back to vote though. I'd like to know the comments for future reference though :)

[hiddenbeats]

could i see the comments for 4 please?

[gia86]

Can I see the comments on mine?

[kateshepard]

Sure! Here you go:
3: The lines that randomly go through her face is distracting. The font color also doesn't match the icon.
3: I like the crop but it's very dark which makes the text stick out a bit against it. Maybe a strong light texture over the middle to bring out Aria's skin could have improved it?
3: the color, font and placement of the text really clash with the icon itself.
3: the coloring is a little bit too dark, and her skin too orangy
3: The textures over is too dark and the text doesn't seem to fit at all.

[beats_within]

Can I see the comment(s?) for mine please? :D