The "Stump My Music Collection" Challenge

Feb 16, 2005 13:45

Chris and I are always interested in broadening our CD collection, so I've come up with this game to help us think of what we may have missed. Wanna play?

Post a music style, that you know and like, and we'll see if we have it. If we don't, I'll ask for suggestions, so have your favorites ready.A funny story about music genres ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 12

angua9 February 17 2005, 02:03:11 UTC
Gospel music.

Reply

Stumped us the first time out. pocket_owl February 17 2005, 02:37:35 UTC
Aside from some individual pieces on soundtrack albums and the like, we have no gospel music.

So, what do you like? What would be a good first gospel CD to get?

Reply

Re: Stumped us the first time out. angua9 February 17 2005, 04:00:28 UTC
For a first-timer, I'd recommend the soundtrack to "Oh Brother Where Art Thou." It has some gospel and some other wonderful old-timey Southern stuff. Otherwise, I have a great album called "Amazing Grace" (my favorite gospel song) by Jimmy Witherspoon, and it has most of the standards ("Rock of Ages" "Swing Low Sweet Chariot," etc.). There is another album I don't have, but want, that was issued with the PBS show on "Amazing Grace," with a lot of different versions of that one wonderful song.

Ummm... that's all I've got.

Reply

Re: Stumped us the first time out. pocket_owl February 17 2005, 18:23:28 UTC
Actually, it was the soundtrack to "Oh Brother, Where Art Thou" that I was referring to. I'll check out Jimmy Witherspoon. Thanks.

Reply


Okay, I'll try to stump you :D hymnia February 17 2005, 02:58:01 UTC
And I'll do so mainly by splitting hairs with my "genres"

Early 20th century neo-romanticism (e.g. Barber, Vaughan Williams)
Late romantic Italian opera (e.g. Puccini, Verdi)
Musical theatre with primarily classical style singing (Rodgers and Hammerstein, Bernstein, Sondheim)
Musical theatre "pop operas" (Les Miz, Miss Saigon, late Andrew Lloyd Webber)
Contemporary Christian rock (Switchfoot, Burlap to Cashmere, Sixpence None the Richer, Jars of Clay)

Reply

Re: Okay, I'll try to stump you :D pocket_owl February 17 2005, 18:55:56 UTC
Early 20th century neo-romanticism (e.g. Barber, Vaughan Williams)

What about Debussy? He is considered the father of
neo-romanticism by some.

Musical theatre with primarily classical style singing (Rodgers and Hammerstein, Bernstein, Sondheim)
Musical theatre "pop operas" (Les Miz, Miss Saigon, late Andrew Lloyd Webber)

Which would you consider "Into the Woods" as being? Any further recommendations?

Contemporary Christian rock (Switchfoot, Burlap to Cashmere, Sixpence None the Richer, Jars of Clay)

We have Sixpence None the Richer, The Echoing Green, and Evanescence. I thought there was some controversy as to the "Christian Rock" labeling with each of these, for the same reason. They all have some band members that profess Christianity, but won't label their bands as being Christian, themselves. Was I misinformed? I'd like them either way, of course: great music!

Jars of Clay has been on the to-buy list for some time now, too. What about the other bands: what are they like?

Reply

Re: Okay, I'll try to stump you :D hymnia February 17 2005, 21:02:39 UTC
Debussy is good. But as I singer, I'm partial to vocal music, and Barber and Vaughan Williams did some fantastic art songs in this genre. I performed most of Barber's Hermit Songs on my senior recital. Here's a bit from my performance notes:

The ten-song cycle Hermit Songs is a result of his love for Irish poetry and literature coupled with his affinity for vocal music. In the early 1950s, he stumbled upon several collections of texts written by Irish monks and scholars in the eighth through the fourteenth centuries. Often these men simply scribbled a thought or a fragment of poetry in the margins of manuscripts they were copying...

With the Hermit Songs, Barber displays his skill for solo song setting. Modal melodies and open harmonies evoke the simplicity of medieval monastic life, yet rhythmic complexity and metric fluidity bring to life the nuances of the varying themes and moods in the texts.What about late romantic Italian opera? I didn't see an answer for that one ( ... )

Reply

Re: Okay, I'll try to stump you :D pocket_owl February 17 2005, 21:34:26 UTC
Modal melodies and open harmonies evoke the simplicity of medieval monastic life, yet rhythmic complexity and metric fluidity bring to life the nuances of the varying themes and moods in the texts.

Barber sounds good. We will definitely check that out.

What about late romantic Italian opera? I didn't see an answer for that one.

Sorry, forgot. Got Verdi. (Sounds like an art music ad: Got Verdi?)

My recommendation in that area is Les Miz.

I read Le Mis' a long time ago, and saw the play, and sang the song in chorus in high school, but I don't have the soundtrack - mean to, though. Have anything out of the ordinary you can turn me on to?

I won’t get into semantics too much. I’ll just say that I let the radio stations define it for me

I have heard all those bands (including U2, which I have but forgot to include) on Christian radio at some time or another. I think there was a really big stink about Evanescence a while back when everybody thought they were a Christian band, then got all mad when they found out they weren't. A lot ( ... )

Reply


connielane February 17 2005, 03:25:17 UTC
English madrigals

Reply

This game is working too well ... pocket_owl February 17 2005, 19:02:08 UTC
Well, we have tons of Medieval and Renaissance dance music, some with lyrics, and a couple of albums by the Mediaeval Baebes. Does that count?

So, where should I start?

Reply

Re: This game is working too well ... connielane February 17 2005, 19:07:47 UTC
Most of the madrigals are meant to be a cappella, though some occasionally are accompanied by one or two instruments.

The Cambridge Singers have several CDs of madrigals, but a great one to start with is Flora Gave Me Fairest Flowers. The King's Singers have also done a few madrigal albums (though they'll sound a bit different, since they're 6 men, as opposed to a bigger mixed group). A good one from them would be All At Once Well Met.

Reply


How about... tobyrne April 2 2006, 19:34:56 UTC
how's your folk music collection? any sea shanties?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up