Belated Review: Sherlock Holmes

[pocket_size_g]

I thoroughly enjoyed A Study in Pink. I thought it was a very good adaptation of Sherlock Holmes, and it worked remarkably well in a modern setting.

Comments

[omylouse]

This pretty much sums up my thoughts exactly :)

[david_bartram]

While Mycroft was indeed over the top, I did love the Mycroft/Moriarty fake-out.

"So, it really is a childish feud?"

Otherwise, I agree with pretty much everything you said. Oh, and could someone who's read more of the Doyle stories confirm this suspicion of mine: I heard a long time ago that Watson's wound moves from his leg to his shoulder in Doyle's stories (presumably due to bad notekeeping on the author's part). If this is true, then I thought that Moffat referenced it very cleverly.

-Dave

[david_bartram]

Well, episode two was a crushing disappointment!