Comments | potcsues: Aki Birch

potcsues

Aki Birch

Jan 19, 2004 00:23

You know, there's so much fic that's just bad, I sometimes regret that I only report Suefic. Like this, for instance. I wanted it to be a parody, just for the sake of my faith in humanity. Unfortunately, it doesn't seem to be.

TITLE: Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of Love
CULPRIT: Grace Leonhart
SUMMARY: "Jack left Port Royal happy and ( Read more... )

Comments 7

mylla January 19 2004, 08:12:11 UTC

(A/n: Hmmm I'm thinking of ending this hear..should I? Could I? I could definitely because you're not the one writing it ^_^ just to end your suffering I'll write a bit more)

Ooh, thank you! Yes, because:
a) We're so wrapped up in your Mary Sue it would be terribly painful if you stopped just here, and
b) That was SUCH a cliffhanger - you'd just told us something we already knew! Gasp!

*rolls eyes*

windsong_moon January 19 2004, 15:35:14 UTC

Thats really actually quite boring. I hate Boring!Sues. At least the ones with talking tigers and sing Madonna songs are funny.

*is tempted to flame author*

*is tempted to go re-read the PotC talking tiger fic*

Oh, THAT fic. Tigress Song, I believe it was called? araeph January 24 2004, 06:57:34 UTC

That fic has been removed from ff.net, presumably by the author. *sob* I know, I know. It's a heartrending tragedy.

*brightens up*

Fortunately, the PPC'd version is available on Megan@Midnight's story, PPC:Pirates of the Caribbean, where the Sue meets a grisly end.

Re: Oh, THAT fic. Tigress Song, I believe it was called? windsong_moon January 25 2004, 16:33:07 UTC

Yes, that one. I reported it to Mary_Sues a while back. Of course, I was so disgusted by it I didn't make a profile. It was physically impossible.

Re: Oh, THAT fic. Tigress Song, I believe it was called? windsong_moon January 25 2004, 16:34:50 UTC

Or rather- the Marysues community. Silly me.

5urf_r1d3r January 20 2004, 00:07:58 UTC

*twitch* Aki....No. Bad. Japanese names are fine. For JAPANESE characters. And...in PotC? I don't think so...*twitch*

livilla January 20 2004, 05:21:37 UTC

That is just so... UGH!

The only thing that was worse was reading the "reviews". Only about three had constructive criticism. The rest were all "OMG Lolz! ThAt r0xers!!!!!!!!!!!1!!#@!!!!one!"

I think I need to go... burn... something now. Yick.