The ICON CRIT meme

[powercorrupts]

Anonymous icon critique meme

Do you ever wonder if there's something that you could improve with your icons, or have you ever wanted to tell someone that there's one thing that they do phenomenally, but you're afraid to leave a comment logged in? Do you just want a no-risk place to get icon concrit from, without the stress

Comments

[already]

don't really consider myself as an icon maker but i need concrit :3

airinojoo @ breakuptheshell

Bother....had to go up and read the post...hehehe <3

[winterbubbletea]

One comment and I am being contrary and staying logged in!

"Yeeeeeee.....hwa!!"

Ai-ren is super awesome at icons! :P

Re: Bother....had to go up and read the post...hehehe <3

[already]

silly goose :3

thanks darling, but i still have much to learn XD

[sheaux]

you don't post to those graphics communities like asian_graphics and whatnot, do you? cause if you did, i'd have seen you around.. i'm joining the comm if that's the kind of icons you're making!

oh, but in #4, jae is a little difficult to make out. minmin is beautiful in #5 though. <333

[already]

i post in rising__sun most of the time, but will take note to crosspost more afterwards :D

yepp, i realized i need improvement of my cropping. thanks for the concrit, and for joining the comm too <3

[sheaux]

can't help it, i'm an icon!whore, more precisely, a DBSK/SHINee icon!whore. XD

[already]

SHINee <33 *mental note to icon SHINee next* XD

[ddreaming]

make icons more often!

[already]

my laziness deserves to be shot i know Dx
and you need to inspire me moar!

[ddreaming]

what do i have to do?

[already]

tutoriallls, especially on texture use :) and coloring too if you have time 8Dv want to ask for more jaejoong/yunho icons, but i'm going to be good now :3

[ddreaming]

oh i forgot about a tut
any special wishes or pictures you want to see a tut of
wanna see more yunjae or individual ones? i don't mind doing them <3333

[already]

i'd love tutorials on these Tina :D

[ddreaming]

it was a long time i did those and i never save any psd lol but i'll do my best to redo them or do anyting similar

haha ok i'll have that in mind

[already]

thank you so much Tina <333
if you have to redo them, then i'll go with number 1 and 3 only :)

\:D/

[ex_caps]

yes, i agree. D