Results Round 1 Challenge 1

[love_kate_walsh]

Comments

[ms_shalimar]

Ooh, thanks for mod's choice! I'd love a banner if that's not too much trouble.

Also, could I please have the comments for my icon? #3

[love_kate_walsh]

Your comments:
+ Lovely selection of texture added.
+ I love the swirlies & the color!
- he coloring is too dark. actually it seems like somebody didn't do anything with the colors...

And I'll get right on your banner ;)

[love_kate_walsh]

Here's your banner: http://i181.photobucket.com/albums/x310/love_kate_walsh/Challenges/procter_lims/ModsChoiceR1C1.png

[basta_tragedy]

oh, thanks!! I would appreciate a banners, as it's the first time I got a PC ^_^

[love_kate_walsh]

Sure, I'll get right on it ;)

[love_kate_walsh]

Here's you banner: http://i181.photobucket.com/albums/x310/love_kate_walsh/Challenges/procter_lims/PeoplesChoiceR1C1.png

[welleg_fic]

I'd be interested in my comments as well. I'm still new at the icon thing, so I know I have room for improvement.

[love_kate_walsh]

Sorry for the delay. Here are your comments:
- Too light
- I feel that there's not enough color, and a little messy.
- bad coloring, the colors themselves are way too dull, and these strange yellow stripes don't fit in.
- Icon is far, far too washed out and pale, and there appears to be random odd streaks of yellow in her hair where they shouldn't be.
+ it's very original and stands out the other

[czarnalukrecja]

I would love to know the commets to my icon, it was #7 :)

and, of course, congratulations to all the winners :)

[love_kate_walsh]

Sorry for the delay I never recieved an email that you commented here =S

Here are your comments:
+ good crop, good vivd coloring, although less contrast would be better, but in general it looks good.
- the color is very sharp; almost too sharp