Shalom-fiction

Aug 11, 2008 14:50

Huh, turns out that I've read the winner of the Best Novel Hugo before it won the award for once. Which means it's a good time to mention that I read it and loved it.


Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 5

debkakes August 11 2008, 22:28:05 UTC
My favorite book of 2007, hands down! Loved everything about it. MC even manages to throw in gay rights!

Reply

criollo August 12 2008, 01:28:51 UTC
Sounds like I will have to give MC another try. K&C had me garking on the first 3 pages. Thanks for the review(s)!

Reply

psydid August 12 2008, 02:09:35 UTC
I had some really mixed feelings about that book. He dumps so much rough shit on the characters that it began to feel too intentional. I later figured that's kinda the point of the book - the great distance between our fantasies (comic book heroes beating up Hitler and getting the girl) and our ugly reality.

But it was kinda like he did it as a way to sacrifice his own idols, because all through the book you could tell he still really loved his characters and his comic books. Like maybe it was a book he just had to write? I don't know. But while I couldn't get through K&C again, it seems like he got something out of his system. I finished this book with a sigh of relief.

Reply

debkakes August 12 2008, 05:04:48 UTC
I enjoyed K&C okay, but this novel is 100X more compelling, the voice is so much clearer and more sympathetic. And fookin' hylarious. The plot is ridiculously baroque. He carries it off, because I think MC has dumped a bunch of ego along the way. He would have had to, to write this novel.

By the way, I HATED Mysteries of Pittsurgh. One extended masturbatory exercise. Yek. Enjoyed the Wonder Boys movie, but mostly because of the cast.

Reply


scothen_krau August 11 2008, 22:48:21 UTC
I'll have to put it on the top of my list now. I'm happy for Chabon, I like him better all the time.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up