(Untitled)

[quietsiege]

I recently made a Beatles CD for someone who owned only a copy of the Beatles' 1. This was fun not only because it gave me an excuse to listen to a whole bunch of Beatles songs but also because I think that it's interesting as an academic exercise.

Comments

[jackson_m_pongo]

An interesting premise. What is the goal of this academic exercise? Showcasing breadth? Demonstrating pure songwriting genius? Making fun of Ringo?

(Sorry for the prolonged silence, by the way. I should actually have a computer in the next few weeks, which may help rectify the situation.)

[quietsiege]

Nice to have you back, Pete.

I suppose the goal would be to identify the most vital Beatles songs outside of those that were #1 hits. I would imagine that it's sort of similar to what Paul McCartney went through when he compiled the second disc to Wingspan.

[jackson_m_pongo]

Vital, eh? Interesting. Of the top of my head, I think that "Here Comes the Sun" is a requirement. I've also been somewhat partial to "Dear Prudence". "All My Loving"? "Drive My Car"?

You know what I think would also be an interesting academic exercise? "The Beatles: Chaff", a collection of nothing but filler. I think it's surprisingly difficult; even the lesser songs tend to have some redeeming quality. For example, I can't stand the lyrics to "Taxman", but that is a killer McCartney guitar part. If I didn't speak English, I'd love the song. Bonus points if you can make the list without any covers. So far, "Savoy Truffle" is my leading contender...