(Untitled)

Nov 12, 2007 02:16

Long time, no post. Revision of my thesi due tomorrow. Brain still fritzy. Ah ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 16

idsharman November 12 2007, 10:37:10 UTC
It took this for you to recognise Whedon's genius?

He's certainly done what no other X-writer before him could - made Scott interesting.

Reply

rahneregina November 12 2007, 11:28:52 UTC
It did not. Even if I weren't a Firefly fan, the "Katya, am I finally dead?" scene was a masterstroke, in my opinion. Still, he's most definitely been driving it home ever since Scott woke up with his eyes open. I've constructed entire happy AU X-Verse's around Scott's not getting hit in the head when he was 9, and Whedon totally sees the same point.

Reply

idsharman November 12 2007, 11:39:54 UTC
One thing that's always frustrated me about both Scott and Rogue is that Professor X was supposed to be helping both of them gain control of their powers, and he's done pretty much nothing in that direction, in Scott's case, for almost 45 years.

Reply

rahneregina November 12 2007, 14:20:54 UTC
Well,when you get right down to it, Kitty was right. Professor Xavier is a jerk. And Marvel does not pay attention to what it has already written, of course, a fact that has gotten so much worse in recent years.

Reply


katherinemorrow November 12 2007, 14:59:49 UTC
good luck, darlingest girl!!!

Reply

rahneregina November 12 2007, 20:44:00 UTC
Thanks.

Reply


kali921 November 12 2007, 15:47:08 UTC
Hear hear. But we had to endure 23 ISSUES of Emma being so irritating that I wanted to swat her off the page and Hank getting underused to GET THERE.

That last six pages in AXM #23 were, in a word, astonishing. Scott wrecking someone's face and DECAPITATING him? Now THAT's the Scott I want to see more of. I jumped up and shouted in glee when I got to the double page spread.

Maybe with Ellis, Hank will get used more. And sound like himself.

Reply

rahneregina November 12 2007, 20:43:18 UTC
My hatred for any attempt to make Emma Frost a heroine is so boundless that I just have to turn the natural reactions to her off. Although that time she asked someone to kill her? That was nice. Just needed a bit more followthrough. With actual Emma-killing.

And the last line? Scott owned that line.

More and proper Hank would be good.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up