Windows 7 expiration stupidity

May 05, 2009 11:18

So some people are freaking out over the Win 7 RC expiration. On March 1st, Windows 7 RC will start shutting down every 2 hours. 2 weeks before that, there will be a warning to that effect. On June 1st, it will expire completely ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 7

wh17m4n May 6 2009, 02:41:39 UTC
To be fair, if it is a year trial ending in June, why cripple it with this bizarre rebooting thing for 3 months, when something as simple as a taskbar popup window would suffice?

I am happily surprised at this 1 year free demo thing, but that mechanism just seems like it is designed to annoy people.

Reply

randomengy May 6 2009, 03:46:41 UTC
Two points:

1) As software developers, basically the worst thing you can do is destroy a user's work.
2) Popup messages can be dismissed easily and many users are used to doing so.

They are absolutely trying to avoid a situation where a user is locked out of their computer. When the taskbar notifications don't work, they escalate the annoyance to the 2-hour reboots to make certain that the user exits the RC on his own terms, rather than with a hard lockdown.

A lot of people will take the stance that "if they are too stupid to ignore the popup warnings, they deserve to lose all their data." But punishing users with data loss is just a juvenile move just leads to pissed off customers.

The bottom line is you have two choices:
A) After some reminders, on X date, the OS deactivates and you can't use it anymore.
B) After some reminders, on X date, you get a grace period where your computer reboots every two hours. 3 months later, the OS deactivates.

You think A is better? Really?

Reply

greedyalgorithm May 6 2009, 16:18:45 UTC
But in B, Microsoft is screwing you by giving you 9 months of free trial instead of the "full" 12 months that you deserve!

It's not a 1 year free demo. Anyone (Microsoft or not) representing it as one is the one making the error. Perhaps Microsoft should have decided to make it a "1 year free demo thing", with 3 months of 2-hour reboots afterward? Maybe, who knows.

Reply

wh17m4n May 7 2009, 00:41:48 UTC
That is a valid point, but I feel like it could be better done ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up