There's nothing interesting here, shoooo......

[randomjitter]

okay, if you insist, go to my memory and read my entries on some Harry Potter related discussions (currently there's only one).

And please keep an open mind when you read. I know how JKR wants us to interprete these, but let's see if things look the same when seen from a different angle.

Comments

Since you asked...

[cmwinters]

> But again, you are making two different arguments. One of which is, at least, canonically supported, that if Tom was evil from birth her choice theory goes out the window.

However, the lack of evidence to the contrary does not indcate a presence of evidence to support your theory...in fact, the evidence leads us to believe *otherwise*, and you fervently refuse to acknowledge that.
And you replied:

in fact, the evidence leads us to believe *otherwise*, and you fervently refuse to acknowledge that.

Perhaps your own fervency is affecting your judgment also?

I never refused to acknowledge anything if presented enough evidence. Nor do I refuse to acknowledge the possibilities faced with lack of evidence either way.

Although I'm not sure to what your comment is refering in this case. If you'd care to specify, I'd be more than happy to let you know if I acknowledge it or not.

This is not meant to offend, but I'm taking offense of your comment - "you fervently refuse to acknowledge that"...
I don't think I'm being overly fervent. You