Breaking Dawn - Ch. 4 - Gesture

[kisuvampyr]

Book: Breaking Dawn
CHAPTER(S): Ch. 4 - Gesture
Synopsis:
The vows are said and done and now it's time to party under the flowers and trees of the Cullens back yard. Denali clan is met and a very special visitor brings joy and conflict to the party.

Possible Discussion Points:-Finaly meeting Tanya, was she what you expected

Comments

I actually liked this chapter

[kisuvampyr]

I actually enjoyed this chapter, it had much less cheese I think. ( or maybe I just don't want to admit the other ones made me cry and I don't like to cry).

I don't think I like that Mike ended up with Jessica , but I do wish we knew what he was thinking when dancing with Bella ;) And the part about him getting the garter in the face was PRICELESS!

I'll skip over the Jake part cause I love Jake and it kinda made me cry, poor kid, couldn't be easy. Sure he shouldn't have overreacted like that but I understand his concerns.

Alice being annoying when Ed and Bell just wanted to make out was also priceless, I'll never get tired of Alice.

The goodbye with Charlie again almost drew tears out of me, he's a big lug, I thought it was sweet how Renee was holding his hand at the end though, it's nice when people still get along.

Re: I actually liked this chapter

[catchester]

I pretty much agree with your asessment.

I loved Jake turning up, and Edward being fine with it and then Jake ruined it! Which i still loved in a 'love to hate you' kind of way. Not that i hate Jake, but he does piss me off sometimes.

Loved how normal the Denali's were, no teen temper tantrums (thank god).

We didnt get to see what the wedding presents were though. I'd have loved to see what Mike, Jessica, Lauren and Charlie got them.

And i'd have loved to know what Mike was thinking too. Have you read Midnight Sun? I love it because with Edward we dont just get a look into his mind, but the minds of those around him too. Mike was especially fun.

Re: I actually liked this chapter

[kisuvampyr]

I'm still only about 6 pages into Midnight Sun, just have alot going on lately, but they are telling me I need to hanker down and read it, if anything for the Emmett Lolz.

Funny how I started the series being a Hardcore Jasper girl, and now Im like the Emmett Fangirl elect XD

Re: I actually liked this chapter

[catchester]

I think Jasper is the steriotypical strong, silent type. The mystery makes him attractive.

Emmett is more of a 'wear your heart on your sleve' kinda guy, but the more you know, the more you love.

And they're right, you must must read NOW!

And i dont know if anyone told you, so i will. Some of the pages (not many) are out of order so it's easier to read if you print it first, rather than scrolling up and down.

Kate

[kisuvampyr]

"Keep the dream alive!"

That quote is where I started loving her XD

Re: Kate

[elmathelas]

Me too! I loved that wry little aside. It made her seem really... well, I was going to say human, but clearly that's the wrong word.

[chrisfaithalin]

I felt bad for Jake as well. Poor kid had no idea what to do. And I would have freaked out like he did too. And you got love poor angsty Edward doubting himself. I mean come on, its not a true Bella/Edward anything with Edward thinking atleast one negative thing about himself or their relationship. Taking from Potter Puppet Pals when I saw that Edward practically walks around banging his head against the wall muttering "angst, angst, angst"

[kisuvampyr]

OMG POTTER PUPPET PALS! SO TRUE!

We should make Twilight Puppet Pals :p

Loved it.

[breakingdawnx]

I think everyone did expect Tanya to be on top of Edward and going "Edward i love you" Kinda thing i didn't expect that at all...i did expect her to be the way she was in Breaking Dawn nice and except edward and bella together.
I didn't like the way Edward was going around being so sad and useless.
I wanted to kill him.I didn't like Jacob pov i hate him even more now!
As well at the wedding he was violently shaking her and im like Whoa! Get off her! Loser much and then the wedding wasn't special enough it left me down alot.
I hate when edward is like im a monster waaa! waaa! waaa! I'm a Edward fan but give it up! T_T Hes worse than bella.
Renesmee was a suprize i didn'y expect that and then theres some people saying they expected that but how could you expect that? :S

Lex

Re: Loved it.

[kisuvampyr]

Ummm I like some of your points but, we are discussing Chapter by chapter so you are kinda jumping ahead a bit there talking about Renesmee and what not, some people aren't even done reading the book yet.

Tanya / Jake / Humans

[shadybrightside]

I don't really know what my expectations were of Tanya, but obviously the entire fandom had HUGE ones, so I was aware of the *possibilities*. And okay, she was so..normal. She didn't cause any drama and yes. She didn't do anything. She did more in Midnight Sun o_O I was glad, though, that she wasn't Jake's imprintee. Oh. And thanks SM for putting the Tanya quote on your MySpace. Way to get everyone hyped up for NOTHING o_O

Re: Tanya / Jake / Humans

[kisuvampyr]

I miss the Posse tooo! And I was sooo happy jake was back, even though his overreaction frustrated me, if anything cause he was in pain over it. And you are right he should have expected it at least, I mean, they are MARRIED. Wonder if he knows where babies come from :p

*gets Emmett to do another powerpoint presentation*

Re: Tanya / Jake / Humans

[shadybrightside]

The Posse shouldhave been more involved in this book, ugh! I loved in Eclipse during the prom after party when Emmett was grinning at Mike and people were all scared of Jasper. There should have been more scenes like that during the reception, ESP since there were so many vamps AND wolves present!

lmao Jake would cry if Emmett gave him a ppt presentation.

Re: Tanya / Jake / Humans

[xxsugamamaxx]

i was soooooo happy jacob came back. im not a huge "team jacob" fan but i like the kid. i dont want to see him hurt and i want to see him happy. i liked how even though jacob wanted to be left alone the rest of the pack could still hear him so they always knew he was safe. i think that tie is what let him come back in the first place.