Comments | reborn_battle: Round 02: Challenge 03

coldstofcalndrs in reborn_battle

Round 02: Challenge 03 - Results

Jan 26, 2011 16:52

I apologize for this being a bit late. Unfortunately, we had a tie in voting that we could not break. Since this has never happened before, we're going to have a new way of awarding points if such an event is to take place. Both winners will receive +02 points, and no Mod's Choice will be given. If anyone has any complaints with this rule, please ( Read more... )

round 02, results, challenge 03

Comments 6

anonymous January 26 2011, 22:32:57 UTC

coldstofcalndrs January 27 2011, 02:26:50 UTC

#01 - I love the text composition in this. The coloring is really lovely, too.
01. The crop is really awesome, though it was a bit hard to follow the text, like which direction it was going/the order of words.
#01 - I always love typography especially for an icon creation, and this icon is simply great in my eyes despite the somewhat MQ image
#01 - This one has such a great composition! The arrangement of the text/lyrics looks superb and goes very well with the nice crop. It also has a nice colouring, and the light source plus the darkened spot on the right adds depth to the icon.
#01 - The text here is top-notch and fits extremely well with the image.
#01 - I like the simplicity of the icon and the text is readable while still being interesting.
#01 - I love the creative text placement, the coloring & image used work well with it too.

anonymous January 26 2011, 22:52:42 UTC

coldstofcalndrs January 27 2011, 02:28:35 UTC

#07 - I wish the text was a little easier to read, but the composition is nice and well balanced. I love your icon making style, but it would be nice to see you step out of your comfort zone and try more new things/different styles ( ... )

anonymous January 27 2011, 02:20:57 UTC

coldstofcalndrs January 27 2011, 02:29:35 UTC

006 - the coloring on this is GORGEOUS, and the font choises work well
#06 - I love the coloring, it's bright 7 beautiful. I also like the texture work & creativity.
#06 - This certainly is the most original/thought-out icon from the bunch. The image used was clearly inspired by the title, while it seems that others just included lyrics or found lyrics to fit the image. The typography is also well done and the colors really pop.

anonymous January 27 2011, 02:48:45 UTC

coldstofcalndrs January 28 2011, 00:49:33 UTC

Ah, yes, unfortunately if we don't eliminate, there will be no winner (unless we do like 10 challenges, but that's not how we choose to run it).

#03 - The song match perfectly with hibari personality i said xD but maybe it could be more better if the skintone wasn't that dark
#03 - I like the coloring and the dark purple background helps it to pop.
#03 - The icon doesn't need any lyrics for one to understand how it fits into the theme. I also like how the dark sky/background kind of gives a feeling that trouble is ahead, suiting the icon well.

Also, unfortunately we miscounted the votes for your icon, but we will not change your points because it was our error, not yours!

(The comment has been removed)

coldstofcalndrs January 28 2011, 00:54:45 UTC

004 - the use of textures and typography are really well done
#04 - I think this man gives a poker face vibe with his smile and so..cunning indeed..and I love the typography in this icon
04. I love everything about this! The crop is beautiful as well as the text!
#04 - A bit busy/dark, but I adore the text placement on the bottom combined with the chose image.
#04 - The texture usage is so awesome, I love the crazy amount of text going on in the icon, tho it does feel a bit cluttered but it still looks neat.