Round 01: Challenge 06 - Results

Oct 07, 2010 11:49


We still couldn't get rid of the tie :/ However, both of those who tied will both gain points. Thank you everyone who voted! And I am sorry for the delay!

Results )

round 01, challenge 06, results

Leave a comment

Comments 3

anonymous October 7 2010, 15:52:48 UTC
mychemical_lust October 7 2010, 15:57:29 UTC

#03 - I love this! The crop and colors are so light and fun! And Shitt.P is so cute! I just LOVE this icon!
#03 - The choice of the image fits the theme very well and I love how "silliness" is being emphasised by such a daring close crop and shining colours.
#03 - It really does a nice job protraying silliness and the colors are so light and bright.
#03 - The icon portrays the theme perfectly. The colors give Shitt P. an unrealistic feel, and the designs on her face as well as the fact that her tongue is sticking out show that she is acting silly. The crop also plays into the theme well.
#3 - It's a very witty idea. The colouring is so nice and soft.

Additional:
03 - This might be nitpicky, but it's really bothering me: The tongue is so flat. It has no shading or anything and it sticks out (not in a good way). The blue in the top right-hand corner is also a bit distracting.

Reply


anonymous October 7 2010, 16:26:43 UTC
mychemical_lust October 7 2010, 17:37:17 UTC

#01 - I really love the texture use in this icon. The crop and text placement make for a really great composition.
#01 - /snicker This is super funny, I laughed out loud (actually) when I first saw it. Great colours going on here -- not too bright and not too muted, the colour scheme works well :)
#01 - I love the useage of imagery and text! It made me laugh right away when i saw it!

Additional:
01: The icon fits very well into the theme, however, I find the background and text a bit too distracting from the main focus. The different brushes/textures in the bottom corners seem out of place and have nothing to do with the subject.

Reply


anonymous October 7 2010, 17:53:51 UTC
coldstofcalndrs October 8 2010, 00:06:41 UTC
FAVORITES:
#04 - I think Squalo would make that face if sometime stole his porn stash. Though a bit dull, but the coloring is also nice. And the crop is good too.
#04 - I found this really funny, but I think the text would look better if it wasn't so close to the speech bubble edges.
#04 - The colors are just amazing! I love the crop and use of bars on the bottom and top.

ADDITIONAL CRITS:
04: The icon goes well with the theme. I love how the maker took an image out of context to make it much more hilarious! The border, however seems to cut away too much from Squalo's face and is a bit distracting. It seems like there is too much going on in such a small place. This icon would be much better without the border!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up