On Muslims and statehood

Oct 15, 2013 13:44

Isn't this a brilliant opinion piece?

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/rollback-nations/1180076/0

Leave a comment

Comments 1

recentlyread January 8 2014, 17:14:45 UTC
I am not sure I agree. I do not want to comment on the content, but I have several on the writing. I find it a very poorly written article, with desultory statements that make it more a rant than anything else. I shall elaborate:

Here's the first paragraph:
"The modern Islamic state continues to be a besieged idea.
After the Taliban killed a major-general and blew up 80 Christians in Peshawar, Pakistan is busy rationalising the situation in favour of "peace talks" with them. As if wheedling himself into their good books, a judge in Peshawar questioned: "Why is modern banking still allowed in Pakistan?" He was within his rights because the Shariat Appellate Bench of Pakistan's Supreme Court has indeed banned it. Banking, as we know it today, is banned in Islam, so is insurance and state lottery, but Pakistan is still carrying on with them. Al-Qaeda's Ayman al-Zawahiri condemns Pakistan for not banning modern bankingThe author starts with a declarative statement ("The modern Islamic state continues to be a besieged idea"), and the ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up