reviewinsanity

So what? I'm still a rock star

ayadec wrote in reviewinsanity Nov 19, 2008 06:53

Boy, it's been a while since I posted here, mainly because I haven't had any reviews that made me scratch my head. But I received this one recently and I don't get why people bother.
The review is for one of my comedies (if I have to label a story that way, but I don't tend to think of my writing that way), Roasting Ralph. The entire review ( Read more... )

(Untitled)

amberdowny wrote in reviewinsanity Nov 18, 2008 21:59

This one isn't actually one of mine, but it caught my eye.

Aw, this is adorable. Some SP and grammical errors, but none to bad. Keep it up.
I just wondered how the reviewer picked up on those "grammical" errors that weren't "to" bad, since their own grammar leaves something to be desired.

Hmm.

moirariordan wrote in reviewinsanity Nov 17, 2008 19:11

I just wanted to post this one here because it's funny:

Your story is making me feel something I've never felt before while reading afanfic, which is very interesting to me! Is like... is hard to explain, islike there is a dark cloud in top with the feeling of doom. UPDATE SOON! You're a great writer by the way.*lol* I'm thinking he's not a ( Read more... )

Why don't people pay attention?

lizwinlove wrote in reviewinsanity Sep 25, 2008 16:32

So I got this review the other day.

Well actually its not impossible for step-sibs to get married: on Maury this
girl thought her fiance's dad (who he never knew) might be her step-dad. They
didn't care if they were step-sibs or not they planned to get married. The
paternity test proved that that was indeed his father and the only thing that
changed ( Read more... )

wtf, reviews

So a runaway bride walks into a bar.

moirariordan wrote in reviewinsanity Sep 24, 2008 23:46

On a story in which the main character escapes her own wedding via a bus:

Loved it, I could totally picture everything happening like that. My onlyqualm is when Casey says that the brides in movies never used the bus, thatwas false; in "The Graduate" Ben and Elaine escape Elaine's wedding on the busat the end while she's still in her dress. This ( Read more... )

sure....

i_m_pk wrote in reviewinsanity Jul 16, 2008 21:16

I just got this anonymous review today on "Elements of Style" which is basically smutfic.

"wow, i was reading this and then i saw my hersheys beside me, so i thought i would eat while i was reading. chocolate won hands down on this one lol. but great story!"

What? I'm glad you have a candy bar?

I am a review-spy.

moirariordan wrote in reviewinsanity Jul 16, 2008 13:17

I have no idea if this is allowed, but...you know what? I'm a mod here. So whatever ( Read more... )

there are some who are... "less informed"

mildly_obsessed wrote in reviewinsanity Jul 02, 2008 14:08

First, I just found this wonderful place and thought I'd stop by and share some of the awful reviews I've gotten. So *waves* hello ( Read more... )

(Untitled)

moirariordan wrote in reviewinsanity Jun 04, 2008 02:05

I just got this review on The Interview:

WHAT? this was your fic lwd fic?
this is AMAZING!

There was more, but I was just amused at her incredulousness. Why yes, this is my LWD fic! What exactly was she expecting?

Lol. I'm confused, but it's kind of cute so whatever. Just wanted to share. :D

Honored... but confused

malzadoll wrote in reviewinsanity May 21, 2008 16:37

I just received this review this afternoon:

Hi, I'm an Italian girl and, obviously, a big dasey fan.x3 Your shot is
totally amazing and I liked most that is fit on "incest" theme, that is very
important for all dasey fans. In Italy too, there are lot of people that
define Casey/Derek relationship like "Incest". So, for them and their mental
limit and ( Read more... )