Comments | ripley312: Life on Mars

ripley312

Life on Mars

Oct 10, 2008 01:03

I don't see how the American version can copy some scenes of the brilliant BBC version of Life on Mars, the words, the period dress, even some camera angles yet they don't include one of the best parts of the first episode ( Read more... )

Comments 5

(The comment has been removed)

ripley312 October 11 2008, 02:20:43 UTC

Oooh. I'm so happy to know that you've watched LOM as well. And I agree. The American version will NEVER live up to the brilliance that is the original.

slashedsilver October 17 2008, 08:19:17 UTC

I'm a terrible, terrible person for not replying to your DW discussion yet :(

But hey, I'm psyched to see your post -- does this mean you've finished watching LoM already? :D

ripley312 October 18 2008, 03:14:13 UTC

Yes, I've watched LOM - MANY, MANY times in fact. Once we finish our DW discussion, then we can move onto there? Is that ok? Have you seen the American version of LOM? I want to read your thoughts on that.

slashedsilver October 18 2008, 17:35:35 UTC

Whoa, you've actually watched it many times?! Amazing :) No problem, I'm wondering how you found LoM as well! Though I haven't really thought about it in some time; after the LoM ficathon ended I went through a period of withdrawal.

I haven't seen the American version! Is it any good? I'm a bit too afraid to check it out.

Oh, oh -- have you watched Ashes to Ashes? No John Simm in that one, though.

ripley312 October 21 2008, 01:47:36 UTC

The American LOM is mediocre at best. They copy a LOT of the original but they just can't copy what made it so special.
I haven't watched Ashes to Ashes. Is is any good. I love Gene Hunt, of course, but without Sam.....
So where do you want to start the discussion on Doctor Who? I'm up for anything from Season 4.