Comments | rwhg_ldws: Round 3, Challenge 10: Voting

thesteppyone in rwhg_ldws

Round 3, Challenge 10: Voting

Jun 04, 2010 08:43

Below the cuts are the drabbles and poll for Round 3, Challenge 10 of rwhg_ldws

• Please mark the drabbles out of 10 using the poll below.
• Participants are no longer allowed to vote.
• Please mark ALL of the drabbles. If you don't, none of your scores will count.
• The order of the drabbles random.

Feedback is welcome, just no flaming, bitching or the ( Read more... )

challenge 10, round: 3, challenge: voting

Comments 9

shocolate June 4 2010, 10:55:24 UTC

I thought we weren't allowed to vote??

thesteppyone June 4 2010, 11:39:03 UTC

Okay, So I copied and pasted... *changes* You see the need now, for the reminder in the prompt post?

shocolate June 4 2010, 11:41:31 UTC

so, basically we can count ourselves lucky you were mostly on topic and you didn't just copy and paste your shopping list... or a romantic poem you were sending to your bloke... or the recipe for a cure for something really embarrassing... or the lyrics to an S Club song...

thesteppyone June 4 2010, 11:49:19 UTC

Very lucky, yes. Although S Club lyrics would never be in my copy memory...

willow_wand June 4 2010, 16:31:03 UTC

Drabble 1 - I really loved the style of this one. But what I liked most was how you incorporated two really lovely canon moments. The image of Hermione sliding her hand into Ron's was so beautiful. And I loved that Victoire's middle name was Rapier.

Drabble 2 - Poor Ron. I feel bad for laughing. I think Ron's voice was perfect here. I can only think that Muggles have never been locked up in a dungeon while the love of their life is tortured by Death eaters, or seen their best mate's lifeless body being carried out of a forest. Perfect line.

Drabble 3 - I love how you used the image of the wedding band throughout the drabble to show the cycle of things. I also really liked Harry giving Hermione away. And the last few lines with a pregnant Rose made me cry.

Good job all three of you!

emmacmf June 4 2010, 18:22:03 UTC

Just changed my vote because I realised I'd cocked up - sorry, my lovely! I have it right now.

otterandterrier June 4 2010, 23:19:51 UTC

I had a hard time choosing, so I gave:
8 to the first drabble;
9 to the second drabble;
10 to the third drabble.

I know this might sound random, but it's the way I liked them. It was garder between the second and the third one, because the second cracked me up! But the last one almost makes me cry about Hermione's dad and Ron's mom's deaths.
Great work!

mollywheezy June 5 2010, 20:09:07 UTC

#1--“What name shall you give this child?” asked the elderly robed witch ( ... )