Religion and the Magic of Parents

Jan 21, 2010 10:11


Originally published at SacredRiver.org. You can comment here or there.

Freud famously hypothesized that God is little more than a projected father figure. This idea was given within the context of his psychosexual theories, which have largely been outmoded as the science of psychology has progressed. Nevertheless, Freud was probably on to something ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 2

Naturalism iao131 January 22 2010, 20:42:55 UTC
93,

A note: Naturalism is not materialism, which you say Naturalism "states that there are no mysterious powers, no access to special knowledge, and no non-material parts of reality."

It is entirely possible that mind is just a part of Nature, that there is a Neutral Monist approach that includes mind as 'natural' etc. Nature shows us that its powers are incredibly mysterious - especially on the very large & small scales - and even fly in the face of our normal understandings of causality and the like.

93 93/93

Reply

Re: Naturalism sacred_river January 23 2010, 00:25:18 UTC
Naturalism is a philosophical stance that has four basic positions:

(1) only the world of nature is real
(2) nothing outside nature is necessary to account for its origin or ontological ground
(3) nature as a whole can be understood without appeal to any kind of intelligence or purposive agent
(4) all natural events are caused by other natural events in accordance with universal physical laws

It is entirely possible that mind is just a part of Nature

Not only possible, but highly likely. The naturalistic view of mind/consciousness is that it emerges from physical electrochemical processes of the brain. As such, I certainly agree that mind is a product of nature, as opposed to, say, an immaterial soul (a common belief).

Nature shows us that its powers are incredibly mysteriousNature's properties and processes can certainly be very difficult to observe and/or figure out. In this sense, they are "mysterious", at least until we understand them, at which point they are no longer a mystery. Like quantum mechanics, universal processes ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up