Remember, just before the incident the sub was taking all the women and children (like Miles and Mrs. Chang) off the island. They were also taking Sawyer, Kate and Juliet but they shot out the radio and told the sub driver, take us back to the island, drop us off and then keep leaving the island.
So if the nuke from the incident is what put the island underwater in the flash-sideways... and they haven't said this is true... then that's why Ethan, Amy, Miles, and Charlotte are alive off-island in the flash-sideways. They didn't show Ben being returned to Dharma but I imagine they dropped him off after he was healed.
That also means that Richard, Horace, Radzinsky, Dr. Chang, Richard, Ellie, and Widmore all died in the ALT, therefore Faraday and Penny were never born.
I hope they don't say Ben, Claire, or even Sayid literally "died" ... they had better just be injured... because Ben said very clearly in season 5, dead is dead...
Jack told them what Faraday said, that the nuke would reset the timeline.
Ellie thought the nuke would negate the energy of the Swan station, so 815 wouldn't crash 30 years later and Daniel wouldn't be brought to the island on the freighter. Why would she think anything different?
Comments 5
So if the nuke from the incident is what put the island underwater in the flash-sideways... and they haven't said this is true... then that's why Ethan, Amy, Miles, and Charlotte are alive off-island in the flash-sideways. They didn't show Ben being returned to Dharma but I imagine they dropped him off after he was healed.
That also means that Richard, Horace, Radzinsky, Dr. Chang, Richard, Ellie, and Widmore all died in the ALT, therefore Faraday and Penny were never born.
I hope they don't say Ben, Claire, or even Sayid literally "died" ... they had better just be injured... because Ben said very clearly in season 5, dead is dead...
Reply
Reply
Ellie thought the nuke would negate the energy of the Swan station, so 815 wouldn't crash 30 years later and Daniel wouldn't be brought to the island on the freighter. Why would she think anything different?
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment