Wow these are so lovely especially 2,5 and 7! Not sure about that purple texture on #1 . The image is already beautiful and has some lovely colors so the addition of that purple texture seems a tad much :)
Thank you, dear. Glad you like #2, that is my favourite I think! Aw, I actually like the purple on #1, but I understand how in your eyes it might not be the best fit. I will try to pay attention to colours more.
#2 and #5 are just gorgeous! I also like the style of #7. I have to agree with visionsbeyond that the texture in #1 might be a little bit too much and maybe the left side in #8 is a little too blurry.
Ooo lovely! My favourites are: 2 (so creative), 5 (stunning light and texture), 6 and 7 (colours!), 8 (cropping!) and 9 (neg space! Great crop)!
I am terrible with concrit. AND I've been out of the icon game so long (and was never good when I was in it) that I don't feel like I have the knowledge to actually make any useful remarks. But I'll try because I know you want feedback. Um maybe with 1 the blue light is a little much for my taste. By contrast, on 8 it adds a real interest to the icon. You could maybe use a little less, or perhaps just use a warmer reddish-purple tone? And with 3 it's lovely but maybe needs a little more depth and light to make it... I don't know 'pop' a little more? Or maybe even just a bit of a texture over the top to give it something more? Useless at concrit sorry.
Really though, these are lovely icons, and I'm really excited to see you posting again :D
Wow, those are a lot of favourites! I am glad you like the icons. :)
You are not terrible with concrit, so please get that out of your head! I can see the accurate points in the icons you have mentioned, I will try to work on that in the future!
I know I wasn't such a good friend lately, will try do better... I'm ok, just being really busy and I'm absolutely useless and unmotivated in iconmaking department)) Also, can't believe that summer is almost over ((
That wasn't what I meant at all. :) I just haven't seen you around much even before my long hiatus! ^^ Yeah, well icon-making is confusing for me right now.
Lovely batch! 4 and 9 are stunning, the coloring that you used for those two is perfect for the images. I love the low contrast/monotone look on 5, but on 3 it might need a tad more contrast or maybe some text. But I tend to like more contrast so it's probably a personal preference :) Really the only thing that I can say is 10 may need to be brightened up just a bit because it's hard to see what is going on. Other than that I either like or love all of these :D
Thank you for your supportive feedback! I do think you make some valid points. Uh text, I am not good with it, I either don't know what I want to write or I can't place it, can't find the perfect font, its icky for me.
I actually like 10 the way it is, but then again I know what is going on on the picture. :)
Comments 36
Reply
Aw, I actually like the purple on #1, but I understand how in your eyes it might not be the best fit. I will try to pay attention to colours more.
Reply
Reply
#8 was an icon I was very hesitant with, for me the colour itself that I used is rather unconventional for me.
Reply
I am terrible with concrit. AND I've been out of the icon game so long (and was never good when I was in it) that I don't feel like I have the knowledge to actually make any useful remarks. But I'll try because I know you want feedback.
Um maybe with 1 the blue light is a little much for my taste. By contrast, on 8 it adds a real interest to the icon. You could maybe use a little less, or perhaps just use a warmer reddish-purple tone?
And with 3 it's lovely but maybe needs a little more depth and light to make it... I don't know 'pop' a little more? Or maybe even just a bit of a texture over the top to give it something more?
Useless at concrit sorry.
Really though, these are lovely icons, and I'm really excited to see you posting again :D
Reply
You are not terrible with concrit, so please get that out of your head!
I can see the accurate points in the icons you have mentioned, I will try to work on that in the future!
Thank you for your thoughts!
:)
Reply
I'm glad that you're here again)
Hope, you're doing ok!
Reply
How are you doing?
Reply
I'm ok, just being really busy and I'm absolutely useless and unmotivated in iconmaking department))
Also, can't believe that summer is almost over ((
Reply
Yeah, well icon-making is confusing for me right now.
Oh, have you had any fun this summer?
Reply
Really the only thing that I can say is 10 may need to be brightened up just a bit because it's hard to see what is going on. Other than that I either like or love all of these :D
Reply
I do think you make some valid points. Uh text, I am not good with it, I either don't know what I want to write or I can't place it, can't find the perfect font, its icky for me.
I actually like 10 the way it is, but then again I know what is going on on the picture. :)
Thank you for your feedback!
Reply
Leave a comment