(Untitled)

Aug 12, 2008 08:43

This is just something I was thinking about while browsing the flist, and I realized that I know about most, but not nearly all of you. So for future reference, please tell me:

Poll

For those who are as "awake" as I am right now: This is about how you want people to refer to you, not about the sound of them or anything. Just in case that wasn't clear ( Read more... )

queer stuff, polls, keep your gender off my body

Leave a comment

Comments 33

snuffkin August 12 2008, 13:21:59 UTC
hmm when writing about people in general (and trying to stay gender neutral) I prefer using they/they're. Even though I really don't have a problem using he/his as a general term (esp. in German)

when talking about me I prefer she/hers lol So I really didn't know which one to tick. :O And this is the first time I came across Ze/Hir, btw. :O how do you even pronounce it?

I'm not nearly awake enough for this :O

Reply

scatterheart August 12 2008, 14:49:33 UTC
So I really didn't know which one to tick. :O
I was asking about how you want people to refer to yourself, so you'd pick "she/hers". ;)

And this is the first time I came across Ze/Hir, btw.
Yeah, gender-neutral pronouns are not very common yet, sadly. I pronounce it "seh" and, well, "hir" - I'm not sure if there's an "official" way, actually.

Reply

snuffkin August 12 2008, 14:58:19 UTC
I was asking about how you want people to refer to yourself, so you'd pick "she/hers". ;)

haha ja, I think I get that now *g* After a large mug of coffee ♥

Yeah, gender-neutral pronouns are not very common yet, sadly. I pronounce it "seh" and, well, "hir" - I'm not sure if there's an "official" way, actually.

That reminds me that I'm probably the only person on earth who remembers the time they invented a German word for having drunk enough to not feel thirsty anymore O_O "sit" IDEK why I remember that *sigh*

Reply

scatterheart August 12 2008, 16:29:17 UTC
Hah, no, I remember that, too. I'm not surprised that it never stuck, though - you can't invent a word and go "Ok, now everybody use this to refer to something that you've referred to as something else all your life!" Changes like that need to happen gradually.

Reply


bitter_crimson August 12 2008, 16:04:29 UTC
For my "other", I am good with any truly gender-neutral pronouns. Things like s/he or she/he don't count b/c those are still rooted in the gender binary and thus I don't view them as actual gender-neutral pronouns, though some attempt to pain them that way.

And yeah, I frequently use the sie/hir thing, though it's occurred to me before (and been pointed out to me by others) the issue with confusion with German. IDK, maybe we should all speak Finnish. I forget the pronoun, but someone on my flist who's Finnish told me of a truly GNP native to the Finnish language. I'll have to look it up.

But anywho, I will attempt to remember to associate ze/hir or zie/hir with you. Maybe I will just switch to using zie/hir for myself as well instead of sie/hir, to avoid the German issues. OH PRONOUNS, ALWAYS A GOOD TIME.

Reply

scatterheart August 12 2008, 16:37:40 UTC
Things like s/he or she/he don't count b/c those are still rooted in the gender binary and thus I don't view them as actual gender-neutral pronouns
Yeah, I agree.

maybe we should all speak Finnish.
We should anyway, it's such a cool language. :D But we'd probably fail miserably. However, I'm so intrigued by languages that have actual GNPs in everyday use - it's so hard to imagine even for me.

But anywho, I will attempt to remember to associate ze/hir or zie/hir with you.
That would be great! I'm always a bit worried about, like, imposing on people, because I've gone by female pronouns for so long and it's not like I'm the posterperson for genderfuck. /o\

Reply

bitter_crimson August 12 2008, 17:49:19 UTC
You and I both know the futility of trying to be the poster-perfect "ideal" of some thing! :)

Reply

scatterheart August 12 2008, 18:14:40 UTC
Good point! :D

Reply


honeybearbee August 12 2008, 17:27:34 UTC
'Das' is neutral, right? But it's not exactly a pronoun. There's 'es', but I guess that's more of an it.

And my German teacher would be so mad that I can't remember all my pronouns.

Reply

scatterheart August 12 2008, 18:16:45 UTC
Yeah, "das" is "that"/"this", pretty much, and while there is a small, small minority of genderqueer people who are trying to claim the "es", it's really more for referring to animals or objects.

Why? You remembered everything, as far as I can tell!

Reply

honeybearbee August 12 2008, 21:30:11 UTC
I was trying to think of the others, for examples, and my mind blanked after Sie. /o\

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

scatterheart August 15 2008, 18:48:01 UTC
I'm not even sure there is an "official" pronunciation, really. I say "seh" (although I think others use "zee", but that sounds too much like the German "sie" for me) and "hir" like "his" with an r.

Reply


shiroi_chi August 13 2008, 16:30:47 UTC
I haven't identified 100% female for ages but I still identify with the feminine pronoun--not a girl, but a she, you know? It's hard to separate which part of that is habit, if not all.

And, I promise to try and remember to adjust my pronouns--please point it out when I inevitably forget? It really shouldn't be the responsibility of the person who wishes an unconventional pronoun used for them, obvs, but I'm a glacially slow learner...

Reply

scatterheart August 15 2008, 18:50:25 UTC
I think I know what you mean. *nods*

And seriously, it would be cool if people used "ze", but I'm totally fine with "she", too - especially when I know you know about and respect my gender issues, and the "she" is just a word instead of a category I get put in by default, you know?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up