(Untitled)

[seemag]

I caught a rerun of "Grey's Anatomy" from season 3 on Lifetime and I was momentarily confused because I didn't recognize these people. There was the awesomeness that was Addison, the cuteness that was Finn, and Bailey, oh Bailey, wonderful Bailey. And Karev being all hardened, and Callie with some self respect and Izzie all broken up over Denny. It

Comments

[musesfool]

Yeah, Baltar's harem is skeevy, and I am hoping it has a point other than producing queasiness and occasional hilarity ("I feel god in these boobies" still makes me laugh).

I think Laura is the odds-on favorite, but in addition to Gaeta, I also think Ellen is a possibility - there are many loose ends with her story - and there's also Dualla, who is technically an Adama now, so Leoben's "Adama is a Cylon" could be true - or Zak, or Billy, or Admiral Cain...

[skywaterblue]

If you follow the theory that the Final Five don't resurrect, then I think it can't be Ellen, Zak, Billy or Cain. Too many people saw the bodies.

My guess is Zarek.

[seemag]

My guess is Zarek.

Huh... he would be a good guess. Prominent enough, but not a significant player. My only issue here is that he was also on the execution list with Laura. Then the Cylons would be executing one of their own. Granted, they might not know who these final five are, so that would explain the inclusion, but I'd like to think that whoever triggered the switch in Tigh and company would have done so to prevent the possible execution of the 12th Cylon.

[musesfool]

I've seen that theory bandied about - and it would make sense in terms of the differences - but whoever the prime mover is, in terms of the cylons, took a huge chance with that because there were many opportunities for Tigh, Anders and Tyrol, especially, to die unactivated and unaware.

Of course, it would make sense if the Cylons and the humans are supposed to live in peace that the Cylons would become more human, more vulnerable, mortal...Hmm...

[zakhad]

I wonder if ALL of them aren't Cylons - deluded, estranged Cylons who replaced the real humans years ago and don't know a thing about it, and the Cylons who know what they are don't understand that yet, and #12 will pop up at the end to reunite his/her severed people....

But I'm probably wrong. I agree about Tigh - he's the unlikeliest model. And if they do/can replace actual people with Cylon versions, all bets are off, and who knows what Starbuck is....

Baltar hallucinates Cylon Six. Who says they can't make Roslin hallucinate as well? I don't think Baltar is #12, or Laura. Six told Laura the five were close and she could feel them. I think 12 will be a bit player, standing just off stage, watching the whole thing... like Gaeta or Doc Cottle. I wonder why Six can feel them and Sharon can't?

This is either really great plotting, or really plot-holey inconsistent writing, and it's gonna be interesting to see which....

[seemag]

And if they do/can replace actual people with Cylon versions, all bets are off, and who knows what Starbuck is....

Starbuck, Baltar, and Roslin are something else. They aren't Cylons, mho. I suspect that Anders, Tory, Chief, and Tigh are "replaced" Cylons. To me, that's the only things that make sense. Or they are "sole" models that got really lucky and survived everything to be put in the right positions at the right time. I find that highly unlikely. The Cylons are planners, schemers. I don't know that they would actually take such a statistical chance with 33 percent of their models.

Six told Laura the five were close and she could feel them.

Which makes me even more sure that Laura isn't one of them.

I think 12 will be a bit player, standing just off stage, watching the whole thing... like Gaeta or Doc Cottle.

Me too.

I think 12 will be a bit player, standing just off stage, watching the whole thing... like Gaeta or Doc Cottle.We don't know that Sharon can't feel them. No one asked her. At least not on camera. And we do know