A question...

Aug 06, 2003 15:54

If you knew a woman who was pregnant, who had 8 kids already, three who
were deaf, two who were blind, one mentally retarded, and she had
syphilis, would you recommend that she have an abortion?

Leave a comment

Comments 10

angry_user August 6 2003, 12:59:47 UTC
duh.
I believe the appropriate procedure is sterilization, however.

Reply


hell_on_heels August 6 2003, 13:03:13 UTC
/sarcasm on
Maybe she'll get lucky with this one!
/sarcasm off

Reply


wanderingastray August 6 2003, 13:52:59 UTC
I know the answer to this but I'm not giving it away.

Reply


lorigami August 6 2003, 15:14:41 UTC
Is this a trick question?
If not, the "defects" aren't an issue, but isn't syphilis often fatal to babies?
(not to mention if she's already got 8 kids, isn't that already quite a handful?)
-unless the others were all adopted and this is her chance to have her own, and that really, really matters to her...

Reply


nicker August 6 2003, 15:24:08 UTC
If she has the means to raise all these children to their best advantages, then no. If she's going to bring them into poverty and total disadvantage on top of everything else then maybe. I don't honestly know. I consider myself pro-choice, but if I were the one who was pregnant, I don't know that I could actually go through with the abortion. I might try to find a way to make it work at whatever cost.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up