Yesterday's Doctor Who (spoilery)

May 15, 2011 10:34

(This post mostly cribbed from a reply to greylock )

Amazing dialogue.

Superb acting.

Great hints at future plot arcs.

But...

The Tardis-jury-rig from the Doctor was implausible -- the dead Tardises had been utterly drained of power, as had Sexy, so how were they able to get the jury-rigged one running? Likewise, putting Sexy back into a dead Tardis control room, with *both* of them having been drained of all energy -- nah.

Conceptual villain ("I suck all the life/power out of your space ships from Beyond Time And Space) was OK but we've seen much the same thing several times in Blake's 7 / Farscape / Marvel comics etc.

"Possessed" corridors/planet-surface used to toy with humans as playthings -- straight out of Ellison's _I Have No Mouth But I Must Scream_.

So not *hugely* original, and not totally lacking in plot holes. But still good, and still lots of fun.
Previous post Next post
Up