round 04, challenge six: results

[onew]

round 04, challenge six: eliminations


#02 (-01) by kuronology



#05 (-01) by 0387


round 04, challenge six: people's choice


#01 (+02) by discs


round 04, challenge six: mod's choice


#04 by nudge
→ Good coloring.


round 04, challenge six: tallies



round 04, challenge six: eliminations comments
#02 - i like the concept of the icon, but the backgrounds of the images weren't properly removed, and for some reason that irks me.
#03 - The light texture doesn't belong in the icon. In addition, the textures are flat in contrast to the subject, which has some shadows and depth.
#05 - colouring made subject's skin tone look unhealthy.


round 04, challenge six: favorite comments
#03 - nice colouring and okay use of texture
#01
#01 - creative and unique idea, icon's composition, crop etc is brilliant.