04-08: Voting
Welcome to challenge 8 voting!
4 out of 4 participants have submitted. Congrats to everyone for submitting and making it all the way to the finals.
Participants are not allowed to vote. Placements will be decided by the total number of points earned through the votes on this challenge only.
rules
• don't vote for yourself or ask your friends to vote for you.
• you must vote for every icon - order does matter.
• you must provide a 10+ word crit/comment/reason for your first place vote.
• you may provide additional comments/crits for 2nd - 4th place icons if you wish. you are not required to, it is completely optional, but highly recommended to help each other improve.
• please use this form to vote:
Icon # 1 - Exposition
[+ 3] 1st place - #00 f - crit required
[+ 2] 2nd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 3rd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 4th place - #00 f - crit optional
Icon # 2 - Climax
[+ 3] 1st place - #00 f - crit required
[+ 2] 2nd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 3rd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 4th place - #00 f - crit optional
Icon # 3 - Dénouement
[+ 3] 1st place - #00 f - crit required
[+ 2] 2nd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 3rd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 4th place - #00 f - crit optional
• participants may use this form to give critiques:
Icon # 1 - Exposition
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
Icon # 2 - Climax
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
Icon # 3 - Dénouement
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
For reference: challenge submission
Clicking the links above each icon will show you the original image(s). You should see some of the amazing changes between the original image and the icon.
Mouse over each icon to see the series and character name.
If the icon is included in the voting table I have deemed it to count, please do not comment on whether or not you think an icon meets the challenge criteria.
Icon #1 - Exposition
01
02
03
04
Icon #2 - Climax
05
06
07
08
Icon #3 - Dénouement
09
10
11
12
notes: icons 04-08 and 10 all have two images. Be sure to click each number to see each image.
Voting ends in 36 hours - 1:00pm PDT Thursday May, 19th. [current time]
4 out of 4 participants have submitted. Congrats to everyone for submitting and making it all the way to the finals.
Participants are not allowed to vote. Placements will be decided by the total number of points earned through the votes on this challenge only.
rules
• don't vote for yourself or ask your friends to vote for you.
• you must vote for every icon - order does matter.
• you must provide a 10+ word crit/comment/reason for your first place vote.
• you may provide additional comments/crits for 2nd - 4th place icons if you wish. you are not required to, it is completely optional, but highly recommended to help each other improve.
• please use this form to vote:
Icon # 1 - Exposition
[+ 3] 1st place - #00 f - crit required
[+ 2] 2nd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 3rd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 4th place - #00 f - crit optional
Icon # 2 - Climax
[+ 3] 1st place - #00 f - crit required
[+ 2] 2nd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 3rd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 4th place - #00 f - crit optional
Icon # 3 - Dénouement
[+ 3] 1st place - #00 f - crit required
[+ 2] 2nd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 3rd place - #00 f - crit optional
[+ 1] 4th place - #00 f - crit optional
• participants may use this form to give critiques:
Icon # 1 - Exposition
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
Icon # 2 - Climax
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
Icon # 3 - Dénouement
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
#00 a - optional crit
For reference: challenge submission
Clicking the links above each icon will show you the original image(s). You should see some of the amazing changes between the original image and the icon.
Mouse over each icon to see the series and character name.
If the icon is included in the voting table I have deemed it to count, please do not comment on whether or not you think an icon meets the challenge criteria.
Icon #1 - Exposition
01
02
03
04
Icon #2 - Climax
05
06
07
08
Icon #3 - Dénouement
09
10
11
12
notes: icons 04-08 and 10 all have two images. Be sure to click each number to see each image.
Voting ends in 36 hours - 1:00pm PDT Thursday May, 19th. [current time]