Chocolate Box Letter 2018
First of all I absolutely love crossovers, fusions, and non-mundane AUs. There is a really cool origfic generator, and you are welcome to use it for ideas for AUs and plots!
I'm VampirePaladin on AO3.
DNWs
-Canonically female characters swapped to males
-Mocking of a character's religious beliefs or that they don't have religious beliefs by the narrative
-Mundane AUs
-Fic focused on a character's sexuality or gender identity
-Urine/Feces/Vomit as kink
-Hopeless, meaningless deaths with nothing else after them
-Kara/James, Kara/Winn, Kara/Mon-El, Wanda/Vision, Logan/Jean
Dubcon, noncon, and rape are all fine. Dark fic is also great! Anything from G to explicit is also fine. While I don't like female characters swapped to male, I love male characters swapped to female.
I really love things like fairy tales, myths and legends. So if you are able to use any of those things that would be cool.
For pretty much any romantic character combo (except Harleen/Todd) I'd love a serial killers in love AU that still keeps the core traits of the characters. This can be both being established, one being a serial killer and dragging their love interest into it, both starting out, or however else you want it to be. I'd want the serial killer's to have a happy ending from their perspective.
Another prompt for any fandom: character is secretly a dragon taking human form. This could be really interesting with one of my many ships requesting Supergirl if instead of Kryptonians being humanoids, they were dragons that could disguise themselves as humanoids. Clearly ice breath would just be her breath weapon.
I love monster girls. So AUs inspired by monster girls (or monster boys) would be really awesome!
I love stuff that is post apocalypse!
An AU based on the Fate/ universe would be awesome! I know Fate/stay night the visual novel, Fate/Extella, and Prisma Illya.
Winter is generally my favorite season, but Halloween is my favorite holiday. Doing anything with either would be fun. Haunted houses, costumes, trapped on a snowy night, hot chocolate, all of it is wonderful!
You are welcome to combine ships. If two different ships I've requested share a character then you can go ahead and merge it with another ship to make it a threesome. If you want to include a ship I didn't request in a story that is fine as long as the requested one remains the focus.
Crossover Fandoms
Barbara Gordon (Batman 1966)/Britt Reid (Green Hornet 1966), Barbara Gordon (DC Comics Prime Earth)/Felicia Hardy (Marvel 616), Daisy Johnson (MCU)/Laurel Lance (Arrowverse), Harleen Quinzel (DC Super Hero Girls)/Todd Tolansky (X-Men Evolution), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse) & Claire Dearing (Jurassic World), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse)/Claire Dearing (Jurassic World), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse)/Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse)/Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies)/Wanda Maximoff (MCU), Kara Danvers (Supergirl TV)/Skye | Daisy Johnson (Agents of Shield), Laurel Lance (Arrowverse)/Matt Murdock (MCU), Lorna Dane (The Gifted) & Erik Lehnsherr & Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies) & Wanda Maximoff (MCU), Peter Maximoff (X-Men ATM)/Wanda Maximoff (MCU), Pietro Allen (Amalgam Comics)/Kara Zor-El (DC Comics Prime Earth), Pietro Maximoff (X-Men Evolution)/Kara Zor-El (DC Super Hero Girls), Shona Choudhury (DC Comics)/Kamala Khan (Marvel 616)
Fic or Art
Barbara/Britt
I'm so sad that these two still haven't met up despite there being a comic crossover between Batman and Green Hornet as a sequel to their first crossover. I think these two could have some superb chemistry with great banter. I'd love to see Barbara figure out that Britt is one of the good guys. Maybe they can team up when Batman and Robin aren't around (maybe captured, maybe out of town). You are welcome to include any side or background ships that you want in this. Maybe a fun caper/date? Maybe a plan where everybody has to think that the Green Hornet has captured Batgirl but they are really working together?
Barbara/Felicia
So this is a bit odd in that I haven't actually read any 616 appearances of Felicia. I always loved her in the Spider-Man cartoon growing up. This ship was inspired by the now defunct Marvel Heroes Omega game. Black Cat became one of my favorites and mains to use. I had a blast playing her and I loved all the lines she said in game. I got to thinking that she'd be really fun to pair with Barbara Gordon. Felicia could even make quips about how bats always end up attracted to cat themed villains. I am reading various 616 books, and I'm fine with spoilers. If you want to reference something more obscure or use her from a particular part in her history than just include author's notes.
Daisy/Laurel
Laurel would make a great S.H.I.E.L.D. agent. I like the contrast between the two and their journeys. Laurel starts out as lawful but takes up illegal vigilante activities, becoming a hero. Daisy stars as a law breaking hacker, that learns how to be a trusted member of a team, becoming a hero. If set in the same universe, I could see S.H.I.E.L.D. investigating Team Arrow as well as the metahumans. I could see these two being very dedicated to each other once they got together and would be able to work together really well as a team. I could also see maybe some friendly competition at the target range. I'd also love to see Laurel get her Canary Cry ability be a natural ability instead of a tech one. I could see some interesting comparing and contrasting to Daisy's inhuman abilities.
Harleen/Todd
I think Todd is oddly endearing in X-Men Evolution. I've always wanted someone to ship him with, but Wanda never felt like the right pair for him. I liked his crush on her, but I liked it better as a one sided thing with her eventually seeing him as a friend and teammate but not as a love interest. When trying to think of crossover ships for DC Super Hero Girls I immediately thought of Harleen and Todd. I can see her finding his shows of affection cute and I think he'd love her personality. I could see this working while he's part of the Brotherhood, transitioning to working for S.H.I.E.L.D., or post-graduation for her and when he is working for S.H.I.E.L.D. If he's still in the Brotherhood I can see her friends being concerned with the relationship, but I think that unlike the Joker that he'd honestly care for her even if he's still an antagonist at that point in his life.
Kara & or / Claire
I love Jurassic World. I would love to see what if Kara was Claire's personal assistant instead of Zara (obviously Zara would be working for Cat Grant)? Also, while I didn't request it because I wouldn't want it as its own thing, you can totally incorporate Pepper Potts into this. I love the idea of it and if there was a tag that involved Kara, Claire, and Pepper I would definitely have requested it. I would love to see Kara and Claire at any point in the running of Jurassic World, during the movie, or after it. When it comes to Claire I'm open to almost any relationship if you want to pair her with someone and do platonic Kara and Claire. With Kara I'm fine with her being paired with any Jurassic Park/World characters but I don't want to see her paired with Mon-El, James Olsen, or Winn.
Kara/Peter
I think these two could be a lot of fun together. I kind of like the idea of an AU where maybe they grew up near each other? How would being in a world that hates super powered people effect Kara? I think Peter would like having a girlfriend that he didn't have to slow down as much for and wouldn't have to worry about accidentally hurting if he did use his speed. I think that she could understand his desire to connect with Magneto considering her own family issues. This could also be really fun to have as part of one of the big CW crossovers. In doing a normal crossover something light hearted and fun could be to have Peter express his opinions on things like modern music, the state of Star Wars/Star Trek, etc. I also want to see them eating all the delicious junk food together! Or just a fun date at an amusement park where something might or might not go horribly wrong. I'm fine with this being the teenage Peter from DoFP or the adult one from Apocalypse, you can totally go with an age gap ship between teen Peter and adult Kara. Oh, gaming! In one of the comics it mentions that Kara played video games when younger! Who would be better at them?
Kara/Peter/Wanda
I would like this as an equal ship between all three or one where Peter and Wanda are both into Kara. You can totally play up the incest in this, or even make it more incesty by somehow making Kara related. I would love to see all the AUs with this. If smushing the worlds together I'm open to a multitude of ways to handle Peter and Wanda: cousins, half-siblings, triplets instead of twins, or replacing Pietro with Peter. This ship really makes me think of a them against overwhelming odds. I even kind of want to see a situation where these three might be bad guys together, while keeping their core character traits.
Kara/Daisy
This feels like something I would have nominated but it isn't... So, this intrigues me. I can see the two being a hacker and reporter team. Maybe an AU where they open a PI firm together using their respective skills. Kara could be very supportive of Daisy when she goes through terregenesis. I'd love to see what Kara could contribute with her knowledge of aliens. I don't have many ideas for this, sorry, but I saw it on the taglist and liked the idea of it.
Laurel/Matt - It would be really easy for these two to meet at some point as they are both lawyers. Maybe they could meet over cases that are connected? I'd love to see them in their respective superhero identities together. Would the Canary Cry mess with Matt's senses? I'd just love to see Laurel get together with and be involved with someone that isn't connected to Oliver. I've seen both seasons of Daredevil and I've started but haven't finished the Defenders. You can bring in anybody from the Arrowverse or the MCU as well as any other ships you might want to do.
Lorna & Erik & Peter & Wanda
Family reunion! I'd just love to see all these characters that are related to each other interact with one another. I'm fine with either a traditional crossover or mushing the worlds together. Or if you want to do sort of both, maybe something happens and they started as separate worlds but were merged together. I could see Wanda being very torn about leaving a world where her twin, her father, and her mother are all still alive even if her parents never married in the X-Men movie world. I have this sort of headcanon that the MCU version of Wanda's mother was pregnant with the MCU version of Peter's unnamed little sister from the X-Men movies when she died. I would love seeing Lorna's volatile personality come in contact with everyone else. I can see Peter being a bit protective of all of his sisters (that would be four sisters by now). Nina and Peter's unnamed younger sister are both welcome if you want to go all out on relatives.
Peter/Wanda
So, apparently I'm really into crossover Maximoffcest. I'm fine with Wanda having had a romantic relationship with Pietro in the backstory (I do ship Wanda/Pietro too). If you want to give Peter and Wanda a little bit of sad symmetry, then maybe Peter's Wanda died? We know she existed in the original timeline thanks to a list of mutants and Ms. Maximoff did mention another daughter in Days of Future Past, so it wouldn't be hard for something to have happened to her between Days of Future Past and Apocalypse. I could see an Infinity Stone or Wanda's own powers causing them to meet, that's before all the other comic booky ways they could meet.
Pietro (Amalgam)/Kara (comic)
There is a sad lack of Supergirl in the Amalgam universe. Honestly, if you want to make this instead be about the Kara native to Amalgam and just strongly base her on DC's current Kara then that is fine with me. Would the Amalgam equivalent of the Winter Solider story line be about Kara since she and Bucky both shared the killed off sidekick spot in Clark's and Steve's past? With Pietro being from the future it could also allow for a fun team up with the Legion of Galactic Guardians 2099 (aka Legion of Super Heroes combined with Guardians of the Galaxy). Both DC and Marvel had been events in the past few years that saw tons of universes referenced and crossing over, yet due to the joint ownership of Amalgam, it couldn't participate in either. That would be another fun way to bring it over. I could see Kara and Pietro bonding over being in a strange place, Kara on another planet and Pietro in the past. Maybe Kara's pod accidentally took through a portal to the Amalgam Earth instead of Prime Earth? I could see J'onn J'onzz finding her and bringing her into the JLX. Maybe even noting that she's of the same race that the Super-Soldier serum was derived from?
Pietro (Evolution)/Kara (DC Super Hero Girls)
This version of Kara is just so earnest and upbeat. I could see this version of Pietro the type of character that would bug a girl that he likes. I love how clumsy she can sometimes be despite her powers. Or maybe this can be when he's attempting to be better as a part of S.H.I.E.L.D? Or it could be when he's committing a crime but instead decides it's more fun to tease/flirt with her? Of course this version of Kara would probably become easily flustered at the whole thing.
Shona/Kamala
I love all of the Gang of Harleys, but Shona is my favorite if I had to pick one. In a universe where DC and Marvel coexisted I don't think it would be too unreasonable for the two of them to meet up. Or if separate universes I could see Kamala being absolutely thrilled with her first Marvel/DC crossover (but maybe she was hoping for someone a little higher profile). I can see the two of them enjoying hanging out together but maybe not exactly agreeing on their methods when in costume.
Ame-Comi Girls
Barbara Gordon/Kara Jor-El
Fic or Art
Does this count as SuperBat? Ame-Comi Girls was my first comic and I still love it. There is just so much potential for stories in this world soon. There are so many characters that could be used and introduced, so many potential plot points. Heck, there is still a ton of potential backstory to explore for the characters.
I like the contrast between the very public Power Girl and the more secretive Batgirl. I'd love to see more about what changed with the universal reboot. Is that why Power Girl is suddenly okay with Batgirl being in the Justice League now? How did the Justice League get formed? Do any villains find out that they are together and get jealous (ie Duela)? Is Power Girl still public with her identity in the new timeline (I admit I kind of want to see her with a Karen Kent identity)? Does Batgirl still save Bruce Wayne from kidnappers while wearing a Halloween costume?
I'm also a big fan of the friendship between Karen Starr and Helena Wayne in the main comics, so while this PG is actually this universe's Kal-El instead of this universe's Kara Zor-El, I'd like it if you could squeeze in a mention of their friendship.
DCU (Comics New 52 - Present)
Shona Choudhury & Harleen Quinzel (N52-P), Koriand'r/Kara Zor-El (N52-P), Barbara Gordon/Kara Zor-El (N52-P), Barbara Gordon/Pamela Isley (N52-P)
Fic or Art
I basically started DC with the New 52, so anything from before that would be lost on me. I also really don't like the New Earth Kara in particular. You are welcome to bring in your favorite other characters.
Shona Choudhury & Harleen Quinzel (N52-P) - Shona is my favorite member of the Gang of Harleys. I just want to see something with her interacting with at least Harley, but you can bring in the rest of the gang. They're a case of where I like everyone, but Shona is the fave. I'm open to any ships you want to include as long as they don't involve the Joker.
Koriand'r/Kara - I've only read Kori's solo series, but she's just so wonderful and cheery. I think she and Kara could become really good friends. I'd love to see them find comfort with each other. I think having someone like Kori in Kara's life is exactly what she needs. They can experience everything Earth has to offer together. Maybe Kori could even help her patch things up with Siobhan?
Barbara/Kara - Yes, I loved their team up! I could see Barbara helping her with the normal teenager stuff. I also think Barbara would make a better mentor and friend than Cat. I love Cat in the show, but I don't care for her presence here.
Barbara/Pamela - So they've teamed up twice in Barbara's solo books and I loved them. Especially the one on the plane. I love seeing them work together and that Pamela figured out who Batgirl was. I'd love to see them on a date together, maybe a little bit of action? I can see Harley doing everything she can so Pamela has an amazing date.
DC Arrowverse
John Constantine/Laurel Lance (Arrowverse), Kara Dancers/Laurel Lance (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Earth 2 Laurel Lance (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Laurel Lance/Oliver Queen (Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Leslie Willis (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Oliver Queen (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Siobhan Smythe (DC Arrowverse), Laurel Lance/Mick Rory (DC Arrowverse)
Fic or Art
Kara and Laurel are my two favorite Arrowverse characters. So all my Arrowverse ships involve at least one of them. I don't like Kara/James, Kara/Winn and Kara/Mon-El. I do love her friendship with James and Winn and I did like it when Kara was Mon-El's mentor. Past mentions to Kara/James is fine, I just didn't care for it. However, I really hate Kara/Mon-El so please refrain from it unless it is in the context of her getting out of an emotionally abusive relationship with someone that doesn't respect her.
John/Laurel - They interacted for all of one episode, but I like the idea of it. With John showing up in Legends of Tomorrow I'm sort of hoping the demon that knows Sara's name is connected to Laurel and could be a way to bring her back. Or maybe Laurel is haunting him for some reason and neither of them know why? Or maybe this is set on a different Earth where things are completely different? Like what if Oliver had taken Laurel on the Queen's Gambit instead of Sara?
Kara/Laurel - They've never met, but I love them both and would love to see how this could happen. You aren't limited to just the default versions of them. A Laurel native to Earth 38 or a Kara native to Earth 1 are both welcome, as is versions of them from any other worlds. Maybe Alex and Sara get together and the two become close due to their sisters dating? Or maybe there is a time travel team up that causes Black Canary and Supergirl to meet, then when everyone is back in their proper times and she asks Barry to reunite her with Laurel Kara is devastated to discover her death?
Kara/Earth 2 Laurel - Earth 2 Laurel is so much fun to watch on screen. You can do this almost any way you want: Black Siren redemption, evil Earth 2 Kara, Laurel turning Kara evil. Dubcon is also very much allowed and encouraged in this one. Noncon is also great, though I'd prefer it more in the sense of Laurel corrupting Kara/brainwashing her. Marking and branding is also fine, but no cutting off limbs or massive scarring. If you are going with Black Siren redemption I want her to survive it. If both Kara and Laurel are evil, either through being a parallel universe Kara or Laurel turning the regular one, I'd like there to be clear affection and devotion despite being evil.
Kara/Laurel/Oliver - How would this happen? I don't know. By the time Supergirl started Oliver/Laurel was pretty much over. But, I want to see how it could happen. You don't have to limit this to the Earth 1/38 versions of the characters. If you want to do a parallel apocalyptic Earth where they fight off the hordes of hell to protect the remnants of humanty, that's fine with me! Also, I do really like Felicity so I'd prefer she not be the "bad guy" to the pairing. Maybe some kind of bond would be fun? Or something made them do it?
Kara/Leslie - Even if Leslie turned good and was in a fairly stable relationship with Kara I don't want to see her completely lose her shock jock personality. I am however, completely okay with this being dark, messed up and involving dubcon or noncon. Maybe Leslie discovers that Kara is Supergirl with video she can leak at any time? Maybe she decides to get back at Cat's little pet project and discovers that Kara is Supergirl that way? Even if it is twisted, I'd like to see some affection in this.
Kara/Oliver - I'm amused by the time in an interview where Stephen Amell said he disregarded all direction to stare longingly as Kara. That is the entire reason I want this. I'd love to see this as a version of them that aren't Nazis. Maybe an AU where Arrow and Supergirl take place on the same Earth and that caused Kara to come forward sooner? Maybe a reporter Kara is investigating the Star City vigilante?
Kara/Siobhan - This is partly inspired by the friendship that they shared in the New 52 comics. I would like to somehow see that happen in the show. Maybe Siobhan can go yandere for Kara somehow? I don't want Siobhan to suddenly become super nice, but I did like the glimpses of a softer side of her we got in the show. Maybe Siobhan decides not to kill Kara because she likes having powers and will lose them once she kills the woman that "wronged" her? Or maybe as vengeance she decides to force Kara into being her lover?
Laurel/Mick - I didn't care for him in the Flash, but in Legends of Tomorrow he's grown into one of my favorite characters. There is just something about the idea of them that really appeals to me. I don't know what exactly it is. Maybe the Legends could have a hand in her resurrection but time says she can never go back home and resume her life as Laurel Lance? Or maybe somehow Earth 2 Laurel is braindead and Earth 1 Laurel is brought back to life in her body? I could see Sara having a lot of fun watching the two of them interact with each other, possibly with some teasing.
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Pietro Maximoff/Wanda Maximoff/Steve Rogers (MCU)
Fic or Art
So I'd like this either canon divergence where Pietro didn't die, where Pietro was resurrected, or a complete setting AU. I love that Steve understood the Maximoffs and why they did what they did. I didn't like that Pietro's death felt very Joss Whedony predictable. I'm not sure what I want for this, other than the fact that this is one of the things that I know I want.
X-Men Evolution
Rogue/Scott Summers (X-Men Evolution, Wanda Maximoff/Scott Summers (X-Men Evolution)
Fic or Art
I do love Scott/Jean in canon, but I also love potentially other ships as well. I've gotten some great Jean/Scott in other exchanges but I've never gotten anything for either of these. Even though I'm requesting Scott with a character other than Jean I don't want to see her vilified. I'm fine with it being something where Scott and Jean never got together, they did but they broke up, or set after a theoretical Phoenix arc and Jean has died.
Rogue/Scott - I think something could have happened if she'd ever worked up the courage to confess her feelings to Scott. They share the fact that their mutations isolate them to an extent, she can't touch anyone except through gloves and he can't look at anyone except through ruby quartz. What would their first date be like? How would they dynamic as X-Men change after becoming a couple? What if roles had been reversed and Scott was the Brotherhood member and Rogue the X-Man? They are also both orphans
Wanda/Scott - doesn't have a basis on in universe feelings and friendship like Rogue/Scott does. But I still think they could be an interesting couple. For this one I see it happening more post-series, but I'd be happy to see something set during the series if you have an idea. I'd love to see something where their respective brothers cause a problem for the two of them.
X-Men Movieverse
Betsy Braddock/Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies), Jean Grey/Peter Maximoff/Scott Summers (X-Men Movies)
Fic or Art
So I view these movies as comic book time and I don't worry too much about specifics of how much time has passed or what the characters actual ages should be. I just enjoy that part for what it is.
Betsy/Peter - I'd like to see her eventually join the X-Men like her comic counterpart. I'd also love some more exploration on why she joined Apocalypse. The other three had well shown reasons for being angry at the world. Betsy just seemed sort of unhappy. So some backstory would be awesome! If she later joined the team it would be interesting to see how she'd get along with Peter as the two adult members. Does she have the same body swapping backstory as comic Betsy? That would be interesting. I can see Peter being very enthusiastic about dating a telepathic ninja.
Jean/Peter/Scott - Okay, so this is purely just a case of mashing together some characters I like and hoping it works. You can play with ages if you desire for this one. I could see them finding a sort of balance together that I think would be fun. What if Peter finds out about Scott's and Jean's deaths in the original timeline? What would the dynamic be like by the time that the original trilogy would happen? What would the reactions of their friends/family be like? How does it impact their ability on missions? What about your potential idea of this and how X-Men: Dark Phoenix could play out?
I'm VampirePaladin on AO3.
DNWs
-Canonically female characters swapped to males
-Mocking of a character's religious beliefs or that they don't have religious beliefs by the narrative
-Mundane AUs
-Fic focused on a character's sexuality or gender identity
-Urine/Feces/Vomit as kink
-Hopeless, meaningless deaths with nothing else after them
-Kara/James, Kara/Winn, Kara/Mon-El, Wanda/Vision, Logan/Jean
Dubcon, noncon, and rape are all fine. Dark fic is also great! Anything from G to explicit is also fine. While I don't like female characters swapped to male, I love male characters swapped to female.
I really love things like fairy tales, myths and legends. So if you are able to use any of those things that would be cool.
For pretty much any romantic character combo (except Harleen/Todd) I'd love a serial killers in love AU that still keeps the core traits of the characters. This can be both being established, one being a serial killer and dragging their love interest into it, both starting out, or however else you want it to be. I'd want the serial killer's to have a happy ending from their perspective.
Another prompt for any fandom: character is secretly a dragon taking human form. This could be really interesting with one of my many ships requesting Supergirl if instead of Kryptonians being humanoids, they were dragons that could disguise themselves as humanoids. Clearly ice breath would just be her breath weapon.
I love monster girls. So AUs inspired by monster girls (or monster boys) would be really awesome!
I love stuff that is post apocalypse!
An AU based on the Fate/ universe would be awesome! I know Fate/stay night the visual novel, Fate/Extella, and Prisma Illya.
Winter is generally my favorite season, but Halloween is my favorite holiday. Doing anything with either would be fun. Haunted houses, costumes, trapped on a snowy night, hot chocolate, all of it is wonderful!
You are welcome to combine ships. If two different ships I've requested share a character then you can go ahead and merge it with another ship to make it a threesome. If you want to include a ship I didn't request in a story that is fine as long as the requested one remains the focus.
Crossover Fandoms
Barbara Gordon (Batman 1966)/Britt Reid (Green Hornet 1966), Barbara Gordon (DC Comics Prime Earth)/Felicia Hardy (Marvel 616), Daisy Johnson (MCU)/Laurel Lance (Arrowverse), Harleen Quinzel (DC Super Hero Girls)/Todd Tolansky (X-Men Evolution), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse) & Claire Dearing (Jurassic World), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse)/Claire Dearing (Jurassic World), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse)/Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies), Kara Danvers (Arrowverse)/Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies)/Wanda Maximoff (MCU), Kara Danvers (Supergirl TV)/Skye | Daisy Johnson (Agents of Shield), Laurel Lance (Arrowverse)/Matt Murdock (MCU), Lorna Dane (The Gifted) & Erik Lehnsherr & Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies) & Wanda Maximoff (MCU), Peter Maximoff (X-Men ATM)/Wanda Maximoff (MCU), Pietro Allen (Amalgam Comics)/Kara Zor-El (DC Comics Prime Earth), Pietro Maximoff (X-Men Evolution)/Kara Zor-El (DC Super Hero Girls), Shona Choudhury (DC Comics)/Kamala Khan (Marvel 616)
Fic or Art
Barbara/Britt
I'm so sad that these two still haven't met up despite there being a comic crossover between Batman and Green Hornet as a sequel to their first crossover. I think these two could have some superb chemistry with great banter. I'd love to see Barbara figure out that Britt is one of the good guys. Maybe they can team up when Batman and Robin aren't around (maybe captured, maybe out of town). You are welcome to include any side or background ships that you want in this. Maybe a fun caper/date? Maybe a plan where everybody has to think that the Green Hornet has captured Batgirl but they are really working together?
Barbara/Felicia
So this is a bit odd in that I haven't actually read any 616 appearances of Felicia. I always loved her in the Spider-Man cartoon growing up. This ship was inspired by the now defunct Marvel Heroes Omega game. Black Cat became one of my favorites and mains to use. I had a blast playing her and I loved all the lines she said in game. I got to thinking that she'd be really fun to pair with Barbara Gordon. Felicia could even make quips about how bats always end up attracted to cat themed villains. I am reading various 616 books, and I'm fine with spoilers. If you want to reference something more obscure or use her from a particular part in her history than just include author's notes.
Daisy/Laurel
Laurel would make a great S.H.I.E.L.D. agent. I like the contrast between the two and their journeys. Laurel starts out as lawful but takes up illegal vigilante activities, becoming a hero. Daisy stars as a law breaking hacker, that learns how to be a trusted member of a team, becoming a hero. If set in the same universe, I could see S.H.I.E.L.D. investigating Team Arrow as well as the metahumans. I could see these two being very dedicated to each other once they got together and would be able to work together really well as a team. I could also see maybe some friendly competition at the target range. I'd also love to see Laurel get her Canary Cry ability be a natural ability instead of a tech one. I could see some interesting comparing and contrasting to Daisy's inhuman abilities.
Harleen/Todd
I think Todd is oddly endearing in X-Men Evolution. I've always wanted someone to ship him with, but Wanda never felt like the right pair for him. I liked his crush on her, but I liked it better as a one sided thing with her eventually seeing him as a friend and teammate but not as a love interest. When trying to think of crossover ships for DC Super Hero Girls I immediately thought of Harleen and Todd. I can see her finding his shows of affection cute and I think he'd love her personality. I could see this working while he's part of the Brotherhood, transitioning to working for S.H.I.E.L.D., or post-graduation for her and when he is working for S.H.I.E.L.D. If he's still in the Brotherhood I can see her friends being concerned with the relationship, but I think that unlike the Joker that he'd honestly care for her even if he's still an antagonist at that point in his life.
Kara & or / Claire
I love Jurassic World. I would love to see what if Kara was Claire's personal assistant instead of Zara (obviously Zara would be working for Cat Grant)? Also, while I didn't request it because I wouldn't want it as its own thing, you can totally incorporate Pepper Potts into this. I love the idea of it and if there was a tag that involved Kara, Claire, and Pepper I would definitely have requested it. I would love to see Kara and Claire at any point in the running of Jurassic World, during the movie, or after it. When it comes to Claire I'm open to almost any relationship if you want to pair her with someone and do platonic Kara and Claire. With Kara I'm fine with her being paired with any Jurassic Park/World characters but I don't want to see her paired with Mon-El, James Olsen, or Winn.
Kara/Peter
I think these two could be a lot of fun together. I kind of like the idea of an AU where maybe they grew up near each other? How would being in a world that hates super powered people effect Kara? I think Peter would like having a girlfriend that he didn't have to slow down as much for and wouldn't have to worry about accidentally hurting if he did use his speed. I think that she could understand his desire to connect with Magneto considering her own family issues. This could also be really fun to have as part of one of the big CW crossovers. In doing a normal crossover something light hearted and fun could be to have Peter express his opinions on things like modern music, the state of Star Wars/Star Trek, etc. I also want to see them eating all the delicious junk food together! Or just a fun date at an amusement park where something might or might not go horribly wrong. I'm fine with this being the teenage Peter from DoFP or the adult one from Apocalypse, you can totally go with an age gap ship between teen Peter and adult Kara. Oh, gaming! In one of the comics it mentions that Kara played video games when younger! Who would be better at them?
Kara/Peter/Wanda
I would like this as an equal ship between all three or one where Peter and Wanda are both into Kara. You can totally play up the incest in this, or even make it more incesty by somehow making Kara related. I would love to see all the AUs with this. If smushing the worlds together I'm open to a multitude of ways to handle Peter and Wanda: cousins, half-siblings, triplets instead of twins, or replacing Pietro with Peter. This ship really makes me think of a them against overwhelming odds. I even kind of want to see a situation where these three might be bad guys together, while keeping their core character traits.
Kara/Daisy
This feels like something I would have nominated but it isn't... So, this intrigues me. I can see the two being a hacker and reporter team. Maybe an AU where they open a PI firm together using their respective skills. Kara could be very supportive of Daisy when she goes through terregenesis. I'd love to see what Kara could contribute with her knowledge of aliens. I don't have many ideas for this, sorry, but I saw it on the taglist and liked the idea of it.
Laurel/Matt - It would be really easy for these two to meet at some point as they are both lawyers. Maybe they could meet over cases that are connected? I'd love to see them in their respective superhero identities together. Would the Canary Cry mess with Matt's senses? I'd just love to see Laurel get together with and be involved with someone that isn't connected to Oliver. I've seen both seasons of Daredevil and I've started but haven't finished the Defenders. You can bring in anybody from the Arrowverse or the MCU as well as any other ships you might want to do.
Lorna & Erik & Peter & Wanda
Family reunion! I'd just love to see all these characters that are related to each other interact with one another. I'm fine with either a traditional crossover or mushing the worlds together. Or if you want to do sort of both, maybe something happens and they started as separate worlds but were merged together. I could see Wanda being very torn about leaving a world where her twin, her father, and her mother are all still alive even if her parents never married in the X-Men movie world. I have this sort of headcanon that the MCU version of Wanda's mother was pregnant with the MCU version of Peter's unnamed little sister from the X-Men movies when she died. I would love seeing Lorna's volatile personality come in contact with everyone else. I can see Peter being a bit protective of all of his sisters (that would be four sisters by now). Nina and Peter's unnamed younger sister are both welcome if you want to go all out on relatives.
Peter/Wanda
So, apparently I'm really into crossover Maximoffcest. I'm fine with Wanda having had a romantic relationship with Pietro in the backstory (I do ship Wanda/Pietro too). If you want to give Peter and Wanda a little bit of sad symmetry, then maybe Peter's Wanda died? We know she existed in the original timeline thanks to a list of mutants and Ms. Maximoff did mention another daughter in Days of Future Past, so it wouldn't be hard for something to have happened to her between Days of Future Past and Apocalypse. I could see an Infinity Stone or Wanda's own powers causing them to meet, that's before all the other comic booky ways they could meet.
Pietro (Amalgam)/Kara (comic)
There is a sad lack of Supergirl in the Amalgam universe. Honestly, if you want to make this instead be about the Kara native to Amalgam and just strongly base her on DC's current Kara then that is fine with me. Would the Amalgam equivalent of the Winter Solider story line be about Kara since she and Bucky both shared the killed off sidekick spot in Clark's and Steve's past? With Pietro being from the future it could also allow for a fun team up with the Legion of Galactic Guardians 2099 (aka Legion of Super Heroes combined with Guardians of the Galaxy). Both DC and Marvel had been events in the past few years that saw tons of universes referenced and crossing over, yet due to the joint ownership of Amalgam, it couldn't participate in either. That would be another fun way to bring it over. I could see Kara and Pietro bonding over being in a strange place, Kara on another planet and Pietro in the past. Maybe Kara's pod accidentally took through a portal to the Amalgam Earth instead of Prime Earth? I could see J'onn J'onzz finding her and bringing her into the JLX. Maybe even noting that she's of the same race that the Super-Soldier serum was derived from?
Pietro (Evolution)/Kara (DC Super Hero Girls)
This version of Kara is just so earnest and upbeat. I could see this version of Pietro the type of character that would bug a girl that he likes. I love how clumsy she can sometimes be despite her powers. Or maybe this can be when he's attempting to be better as a part of S.H.I.E.L.D? Or it could be when he's committing a crime but instead decides it's more fun to tease/flirt with her? Of course this version of Kara would probably become easily flustered at the whole thing.
Shona/Kamala
I love all of the Gang of Harleys, but Shona is my favorite if I had to pick one. In a universe where DC and Marvel coexisted I don't think it would be too unreasonable for the two of them to meet up. Or if separate universes I could see Kamala being absolutely thrilled with her first Marvel/DC crossover (but maybe she was hoping for someone a little higher profile). I can see the two of them enjoying hanging out together but maybe not exactly agreeing on their methods when in costume.
Ame-Comi Girls
Barbara Gordon/Kara Jor-El
Fic or Art
Does this count as SuperBat? Ame-Comi Girls was my first comic and I still love it. There is just so much potential for stories in this world soon. There are so many characters that could be used and introduced, so many potential plot points. Heck, there is still a ton of potential backstory to explore for the characters.
I like the contrast between the very public Power Girl and the more secretive Batgirl. I'd love to see more about what changed with the universal reboot. Is that why Power Girl is suddenly okay with Batgirl being in the Justice League now? How did the Justice League get formed? Do any villains find out that they are together and get jealous (ie Duela)? Is Power Girl still public with her identity in the new timeline (I admit I kind of want to see her with a Karen Kent identity)? Does Batgirl still save Bruce Wayne from kidnappers while wearing a Halloween costume?
I'm also a big fan of the friendship between Karen Starr and Helena Wayne in the main comics, so while this PG is actually this universe's Kal-El instead of this universe's Kara Zor-El, I'd like it if you could squeeze in a mention of their friendship.
DCU (Comics New 52 - Present)
Shona Choudhury & Harleen Quinzel (N52-P), Koriand'r/Kara Zor-El (N52-P), Barbara Gordon/Kara Zor-El (N52-P), Barbara Gordon/Pamela Isley (N52-P)
Fic or Art
I basically started DC with the New 52, so anything from before that would be lost on me. I also really don't like the New Earth Kara in particular. You are welcome to bring in your favorite other characters.
Shona Choudhury & Harleen Quinzel (N52-P) - Shona is my favorite member of the Gang of Harleys. I just want to see something with her interacting with at least Harley, but you can bring in the rest of the gang. They're a case of where I like everyone, but Shona is the fave. I'm open to any ships you want to include as long as they don't involve the Joker.
Koriand'r/Kara - I've only read Kori's solo series, but she's just so wonderful and cheery. I think she and Kara could become really good friends. I'd love to see them find comfort with each other. I think having someone like Kori in Kara's life is exactly what she needs. They can experience everything Earth has to offer together. Maybe Kori could even help her patch things up with Siobhan?
Barbara/Kara - Yes, I loved their team up! I could see Barbara helping her with the normal teenager stuff. I also think Barbara would make a better mentor and friend than Cat. I love Cat in the show, but I don't care for her presence here.
Barbara/Pamela - So they've teamed up twice in Barbara's solo books and I loved them. Especially the one on the plane. I love seeing them work together and that Pamela figured out who Batgirl was. I'd love to see them on a date together, maybe a little bit of action? I can see Harley doing everything she can so Pamela has an amazing date.
DC Arrowverse
John Constantine/Laurel Lance (Arrowverse), Kara Dancers/Laurel Lance (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Earth 2 Laurel Lance (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Laurel Lance/Oliver Queen (Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Leslie Willis (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Oliver Queen (DC Arrowverse), Kara Danvers/Siobhan Smythe (DC Arrowverse), Laurel Lance/Mick Rory (DC Arrowverse)
Fic or Art
Kara and Laurel are my two favorite Arrowverse characters. So all my Arrowverse ships involve at least one of them. I don't like Kara/James, Kara/Winn and Kara/Mon-El. I do love her friendship with James and Winn and I did like it when Kara was Mon-El's mentor. Past mentions to Kara/James is fine, I just didn't care for it. However, I really hate Kara/Mon-El so please refrain from it unless it is in the context of her getting out of an emotionally abusive relationship with someone that doesn't respect her.
John/Laurel - They interacted for all of one episode, but I like the idea of it. With John showing up in Legends of Tomorrow I'm sort of hoping the demon that knows Sara's name is connected to Laurel and could be a way to bring her back. Or maybe Laurel is haunting him for some reason and neither of them know why? Or maybe this is set on a different Earth where things are completely different? Like what if Oliver had taken Laurel on the Queen's Gambit instead of Sara?
Kara/Laurel - They've never met, but I love them both and would love to see how this could happen. You aren't limited to just the default versions of them. A Laurel native to Earth 38 or a Kara native to Earth 1 are both welcome, as is versions of them from any other worlds. Maybe Alex and Sara get together and the two become close due to their sisters dating? Or maybe there is a time travel team up that causes Black Canary and Supergirl to meet, then when everyone is back in their proper times and she asks Barry to reunite her with Laurel Kara is devastated to discover her death?
Kara/Earth 2 Laurel - Earth 2 Laurel is so much fun to watch on screen. You can do this almost any way you want: Black Siren redemption, evil Earth 2 Kara, Laurel turning Kara evil. Dubcon is also very much allowed and encouraged in this one. Noncon is also great, though I'd prefer it more in the sense of Laurel corrupting Kara/brainwashing her. Marking and branding is also fine, but no cutting off limbs or massive scarring. If you are going with Black Siren redemption I want her to survive it. If both Kara and Laurel are evil, either through being a parallel universe Kara or Laurel turning the regular one, I'd like there to be clear affection and devotion despite being evil.
Kara/Laurel/Oliver - How would this happen? I don't know. By the time Supergirl started Oliver/Laurel was pretty much over. But, I want to see how it could happen. You don't have to limit this to the Earth 1/38 versions of the characters. If you want to do a parallel apocalyptic Earth where they fight off the hordes of hell to protect the remnants of humanty, that's fine with me! Also, I do really like Felicity so I'd prefer she not be the "bad guy" to the pairing. Maybe some kind of bond would be fun? Or something made them do it?
Kara/Leslie - Even if Leslie turned good and was in a fairly stable relationship with Kara I don't want to see her completely lose her shock jock personality. I am however, completely okay with this being dark, messed up and involving dubcon or noncon. Maybe Leslie discovers that Kara is Supergirl with video she can leak at any time? Maybe she decides to get back at Cat's little pet project and discovers that Kara is Supergirl that way? Even if it is twisted, I'd like to see some affection in this.
Kara/Oliver - I'm amused by the time in an interview where Stephen Amell said he disregarded all direction to stare longingly as Kara. That is the entire reason I want this. I'd love to see this as a version of them that aren't Nazis. Maybe an AU where Arrow and Supergirl take place on the same Earth and that caused Kara to come forward sooner? Maybe a reporter Kara is investigating the Star City vigilante?
Kara/Siobhan - This is partly inspired by the friendship that they shared in the New 52 comics. I would like to somehow see that happen in the show. Maybe Siobhan can go yandere for Kara somehow? I don't want Siobhan to suddenly become super nice, but I did like the glimpses of a softer side of her we got in the show. Maybe Siobhan decides not to kill Kara because she likes having powers and will lose them once she kills the woman that "wronged" her? Or maybe as vengeance she decides to force Kara into being her lover?
Laurel/Mick - I didn't care for him in the Flash, but in Legends of Tomorrow he's grown into one of my favorite characters. There is just something about the idea of them that really appeals to me. I don't know what exactly it is. Maybe the Legends could have a hand in her resurrection but time says she can never go back home and resume her life as Laurel Lance? Or maybe somehow Earth 2 Laurel is braindead and Earth 1 Laurel is brought back to life in her body? I could see Sara having a lot of fun watching the two of them interact with each other, possibly with some teasing.
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Pietro Maximoff/Wanda Maximoff/Steve Rogers (MCU)
Fic or Art
So I'd like this either canon divergence where Pietro didn't die, where Pietro was resurrected, or a complete setting AU. I love that Steve understood the Maximoffs and why they did what they did. I didn't like that Pietro's death felt very Joss Whedony predictable. I'm not sure what I want for this, other than the fact that this is one of the things that I know I want.
X-Men Evolution
Rogue/Scott Summers (X-Men Evolution, Wanda Maximoff/Scott Summers (X-Men Evolution)
Fic or Art
I do love Scott/Jean in canon, but I also love potentially other ships as well. I've gotten some great Jean/Scott in other exchanges but I've never gotten anything for either of these. Even though I'm requesting Scott with a character other than Jean I don't want to see her vilified. I'm fine with it being something where Scott and Jean never got together, they did but they broke up, or set after a theoretical Phoenix arc and Jean has died.
Rogue/Scott - I think something could have happened if she'd ever worked up the courage to confess her feelings to Scott. They share the fact that their mutations isolate them to an extent, she can't touch anyone except through gloves and he can't look at anyone except through ruby quartz. What would their first date be like? How would they dynamic as X-Men change after becoming a couple? What if roles had been reversed and Scott was the Brotherhood member and Rogue the X-Man? They are also both orphans
Wanda/Scott - doesn't have a basis on in universe feelings and friendship like Rogue/Scott does. But I still think they could be an interesting couple. For this one I see it happening more post-series, but I'd be happy to see something set during the series if you have an idea. I'd love to see something where their respective brothers cause a problem for the two of them.
X-Men Movieverse
Betsy Braddock/Peter Maximoff (X-Men Movies), Jean Grey/Peter Maximoff/Scott Summers (X-Men Movies)
Fic or Art
So I view these movies as comic book time and I don't worry too much about specifics of how much time has passed or what the characters actual ages should be. I just enjoy that part for what it is.
Betsy/Peter - I'd like to see her eventually join the X-Men like her comic counterpart. I'd also love some more exploration on why she joined Apocalypse. The other three had well shown reasons for being angry at the world. Betsy just seemed sort of unhappy. So some backstory would be awesome! If she later joined the team it would be interesting to see how she'd get along with Peter as the two adult members. Does she have the same body swapping backstory as comic Betsy? That would be interesting. I can see Peter being very enthusiastic about dating a telepathic ninja.
Jean/Peter/Scott - Okay, so this is purely just a case of mashing together some characters I like and hoping it works. You can play with ages if you desire for this one. I could see them finding a sort of balance together that I think would be fun. What if Peter finds out about Scott's and Jean's deaths in the original timeline? What would the dynamic be like by the time that the original trilogy would happen? What would the reactions of their friends/family be like? How does it impact their ability on missions? What about your potential idea of this and how X-Men: Dark Phoenix could play out?