Pazz and Jop Preliminaires

Dec 05, 2009 12:25

Sorry, Iggy -- I quite liked your Gainsbourgian flourishes but you did not make my P&J top ten ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 13

edgeofwhatever December 5 2009, 20:06:37 UTC
No Demi Lovato?

Reply

skyecaptain December 5 2009, 22:25:17 UTC
She's currently bubbling below my top 20 but won't crack 10. If I could do a re-edit of the album and include "Behind Enemy Lines" on it it would have a better shot.

Reply


koganbot December 6 2009, 01:30:48 UTC
Taylor Swift Fearless (Platinum Edition)

Yes, I am going to allow myself to do this, since I did not vote for Fearless last year.

I have nothing else to add that you haven't heard, I'm afraid. I also think it's safe to say that if you voted for Ashley Monroe's Satisfied no Pazz & Jop poobahs would remember that you already voted for it in 2006.

Reply

skyecaptain December 6 2009, 02:27:28 UTC
I contemplated doing both, actually. Taylor would probably make the Top Ten, and it wouldn't be unprecedented (I think I did that with the Veronicas album last year). But technically speaking I had heard it in 2008, just hadn't spent enough time with it yet. Which is exactly what happened to her first album, too, come to think of it.

Reply

koganbot December 6 2009, 02:48:32 UTC
Ah, but you hadn't heard the six NEW tracks on the Platinum Edition (well, you probably did hear a shitty rip of "Come In With The Rain" that either I or Jimmy forced on you two years ago, but now you can hear the good rip).

Reply

skyecaptain December 6 2009, 02:51:34 UTC
Good point...I'll download the deluxe version and see if I should make some room.

Reply


koganbot December 6 2009, 01:31:41 UTC
I haven't heard your 6 through 10.

Reply


alexmacpherson December 6 2009, 18:04:40 UTC
Really like The State vs. Radric Davis but would vote for The Movie 3D: The Burrprint as my Gucci pick, maybe even The Writing's On The Wall or the Cold War trilogy.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up