Comments | smith_awards: The Winners Are

metebelis_four in smith_awards

The Winners Are

May 17, 2009 12:15

Classic Who Gen: Old Soldiers by astrogirl2
Runners Up (tie): A Row (Or Two) by lost_spook and The Lonely God(zilla) by cryptile

New Who Gen: The Gift of the Mad Guy by sam_storyteller
Runner Up: Light Bending Backwards by trolllogicfics

Classic Who Het: Learn How To Be You In Time by lizbee
Runner Up: Nights Like This by fantasyjax

New Who Het: After a tie-breaker round of voting, the winner is Huntsman by lizbeeThe ( Read more... )

round: 1, !winners

Comments 9

astrogirl2 May 17 2009, 19:47:08 UTC

What?! I won? *blink, blink* Um... Thank you! :)

(And the username is actually astrogirl2, by the way.)

metebelis_four May 17 2009, 20:09:49 UTC

Yup, you won. Congrats!

(Ack, typo. Fixed it now.)

anonymous May 17 2009, 20:32:39 UTC

How exactly were the votes counted? If a fic got three positives and one neutral, is it supposed to be worse than the one that got only three positives? It confuses me a bit.

metebelis_four May 17 2009, 20:38:36 UTC

Neutral doesn't count for anything. It's just for people who want to review everything, and for the benefit of anyone reading the reviews as recs. A positive and a negative cancel each other out; they have equal value. Basically, they're each exactly what they sound like.

In your example, those two fics would be tied.

lizbee May 17 2009, 23:02:05 UTC

Thank you! I'm a little in shock.

anonymous May 18 2009, 02:04:49 UTC

I'd like to thank everyone who reviewed my work, and hope to be nominated again in the future. This was a lot of fun.
And an extra ladling of applause to the community mods!

lost_spook May 18 2009, 19:25:34 UTC

Thanks!!!

I feel as if I should apologise for being runner up for probably my speediest written fic ever, which as one of the reviewers pointed out, is nothing but a conversation between two characters, but I suppose I should simply smile gracefully and accept. Althugh some of those other stories should have beaten that one hollow. :-D

It was lovely to get the extra reviews, with the added bonus (in a funny way), that they weren't all positive. It's quite useful to know what people didn't like.

pitry May 18 2009, 20:17:10 UTC

LoL. that's more or less everything I have to say :)

Well, that and apologies for some of the horrible typoes I made in reviews (and a couple of time my brain melted and invented words on its own), I reviewd several fics quite quite late...