I've seen a couple of people doing this in the past, but always gave up trying it because I never felt like I had icons that fit all the emotions. I still don't. Especially the sarcastic one. I don't feel like any of my icons are truly sarcastic, so I just picked one. Most recently snagged from hushingupnow.
The Icon Expression Meme
.happy. .sad. .angry. .scared.
.disgusted. .surprised. .flirty. .sexual.
.confused. .shy. .playful. .rage.
.hurt. .guilty. .bored. .laughing.
.sarcastic. .tired. .wtf. .pride.
.sympathy. .evil. .innocent. .in love.
YOUR FOUR FAVORITE ICONS
The Icon Expression Meme
.happy.
.sad.
.angry.
.scared.
.disgusted.
.surprised.
.flirty.
.sexual.
.confused.
.shy.
.playful.
.rage.
.hurt.
.guilty.
.bored.
.laughing.
.sarcastic.
.tired.
.wtf.
.pride.
.sympathy.
.evil.
.innocent.
.in love.
YOUR
FOUR
FAVORITE
ICONS
I suppose it shouldn't come as a surprise that this is BSG heavy. This has also made me realize that my icons don't cover a huge range of emotions, as some of these don't feel like a good fit, especially "sarcastic." I didn't really feel like any of my icons fit that expression.