(Untitled)

Nov 11, 2006 13:07

Give me a fuckin' break. Just because the art in a manga isn't OMG GORGEOUS, doesn't mean the story automatically sucks. I've seen manga filled with many bishies (well, the typical fan's definition of that term anyhow) and beautiful backgrounds, but the story itself is pure garbage ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 16

a_white_rain November 12 2006, 00:13:25 UTC
What manga is it?

Reply

staff_of_truth November 12 2006, 00:15:06 UTC
Well, it's actually quite a few of them. But One Piece is one of them. -_-;

Reply

a_white_rain November 12 2006, 00:20:15 UTC
The One Piece art isn't going to work for everyone, but the story is worth it.

Reply

staff_of_truth November 12 2006, 00:22:55 UTC
Yeah, it's a great story. And...I dunno, the art is so unique, though. The character designs also distinguish each of them so well. It's not like the some of the generic shoujo ones I see (like in Kare First Love or Happy Hustle High, I swear they are both practically the same comic).

Reply


nobunaga_drill November 12 2006, 00:53:08 UTC
Even with that point, I'd hardly call the art in One Piece bad.

When you compare the amount of detail Oda puts in to stuff like backgrounds and expressions to a lot of other Shounen manga (hello Bleach), it's really pretty amazing.

Reply

staff_of_truth November 12 2006, 01:01:07 UTC
But I love the art of One Piece.

Reply

nobunaga_drill November 12 2006, 01:29:42 UTC
Yeah... I meant that in a good way. XD

One Piece tends to have a lot more detail in things like background and facial expressions then a lot of others in it's field IMO.

Reply

staff_of_truth November 12 2006, 02:43:43 UTC
Ah, okay! ^^;

I agree. Oda puts so much effort into his manga, in both its art and its story. I'm glad OP is as popular as it is (in Japan, anyway), it deserves its success.

Reply


decultures November 12 2006, 00:57:25 UTC
I think most people judge a book by it's cover, because they like to look at pretty art.

Like me, I really like cute art and I tend to ignore series that the art doesn't really make me think it's cute. Which is one of the reason I rarely read any Shoujo, because I don't really think some shoujo art is "cute" even though it's supposed to be. ( Strangely enough, I tend to think Shounen art is cuter then Shoujo art.o_o )

Reply

weaseldog_ltg09 November 13 2006, 04:49:41 UTC
Strangely enough, I tend to think Shounen art is cuter then Shoujo art.

...I can certainly agree with you on that one. XD;

Reply


heron_advocate November 12 2006, 06:22:14 UTC
I know. Looking back at some of the really good mangas (especially the beginning), the art's not all that spiffy.

Reply


kumagoro_usagi November 12 2006, 09:02:12 UTC
Tell me about it. I love one Piece. I think Croc is one of the funniest things created. XD

Reply


Leave a comment

Up