TITLE: "I've Got You Pegged"
AUTHOR:
starky_cooperPAIRING: Sheldon/Penny
FANDOM: The Big Bang Theory
RATING: NC-17
WARNINGS: Graphic Sex, strap-ons & male anal penetration (pegging)
WORD COUNT: 2,166
NOTES: This is an old story written for
Paradox Kink Meme. Prompt: Penny pegs Sheldon. He loves every second of it.
Apartment 4A was filled with silence and darkness. Though the apartment was vacant, with bare feet, Penny quietly tiptoed her way through her neighbor’s living area.
The boys were currently out watching some movie marathon and wouldn’t be back for several hours. With them gone, it gave Penny the perfect opportunity to snoop through their apartment, more importantly, through Sheldon’s stuff. Penny didn’t necessarily like the idea of rummaging the physicist’s privacy but it was the only way she could possibly obtain information.
Sheldon, her boyfriend’s birthday was in two weeks. She’s asked him at great lengths what he wanted, but being Sheldon with his whole view on gift giving, Penny never received an answer. Dejectedly Penny went to her second source, Leonard. That wasn’t much help either.
It was his first birthday with them being a couple and Penny wanted it to be memorable. She wanted to give Sheldon something meaningful. Something that could top the ultimate, Leonard Nimoy napkin gift she gave him a few Christmases ago. But she couldn’t figure out what to give him that he didn’t already have. She didn’t have a clue where to even begin when it came to getting Sheldon a comic book; he has so many as it is. The same went with video games and collectibles at that. It was frustrating that she didn’t know what to buy her boyfriend.
So there Penny was, booting up Sheldon’s laptop, hoping that by chance it would give her some idea. Once the computer had life, Penny opened up the Internet browser then started skimming through his history. Penny squealed when she saw that he visited Amazon.com just this past Wednesday. The fates were in her hands; maybe figuring out what Sheldon wanted was going to be easier than she thought.
Penny’s brows knitted together when she clicked on the tab. What she read couldn’t be right. Her eyes had to be playing tricks on her. With another click Penny was taken to the site. Penny felt her ears burning, her skin flushing. Going back to the history, it was apparent that the other pages Sheldon visited from Amazon were all for books based on the same subject.
Needing to know if Sheldon did any further research on the subject, Penny hurriedly looked through every day’s history. One of the days Sheldon visited wikipedia and that’s when Penny about lost it.
After reading the whole source Penny sat back and stared blankly at the screen. She was dumbstruck and not all that sure how to perceive the information. Penny practically jumped out of the seat when her cell phone vibrated in her pocket. It was a text from Sheldon saying good night since he wouldn’t be seeing her before she went to bed.
With a quick reply, Penny anxiously shut down the computer. In a rush, Penny raced out of the apartment then into hers. Penny leaned against her door trying to will her fast beating heart to calm down. She couldn’t believe what she read and yet she couldn’t stop the arousing images from floating in her head.
The next few days were hell on Penny. She was skittish every time she was around Sheldon. But the day when the whole gang was hanging out watching TV and Sheldon stood up from his spot and accidentally dropped the remote and bent down to pick it up, his ass practically in her face…Penny lost it.
She gave a little moan at the images that raced her mind, gaining four sets of eyes on her. Feeling all eyes on her, Penny turned scarlet red and quickly averted her eyes from a still bent over Sheldon. Seeing the sight of Sheldon bent over with his head turned looking back at her expectantly, Penny had to excuse herself, forging a headache.
*~~~~*~~~~*~~~~*
It was finally Sheldon’s birthday and Penny was all a flutter. She requested the day off to make sure everything went according to plan. Penny set out to cook Sheldon’s favorite dish, which came out mildly decent. She also went, as far as to baking him a cake, that was another issue. She definitely wasn’t keen on making layered cakes. But aside from that, Sheldon seemed pleased, not that many complaints from him.
As for his gift, Penny opted to give him clothes. A few comic book and video game related shirts, ones she knew he didn’t have. It didn’t surpass “the napkin” but he seemed genuinely pleased regardless which was a big breather for Penny.
Once the leftovers, lopsided cake and recently washed dishes were put away Penny excused herself from the group to shower before bed. Freshly clean in her robe, sitting crossed legged on her bed, brushing her wet hair, was how Sheldon found Penny.
“Hey sweetie.” Penny smiled warmly at her boyfriend, glad that he was finally getting used to using his spare key to enter her apartment.
“Hello Penny. I came to thank you for the lovely evening.”
“Awe, you’re welcome sweetie. Did you really enjoy it?” Penny was hopeful.
“Indeed. Though you know I’m not usually into activities such as celebrating birthdays, I must admit, this one was exceptional.” Sheldon sat down next to Penny.
“And why is that?”
“Because of you. I know how nervous you’ve been about planning something for me. Wanting to make sure I approved.”
Penny smiled weakly, so he had noticed how jittering she’s been. If he only knew the half of it.
“I just wanted things to be perfect.” Penny whispered.
“And they were thank you.”
Sheldon leaned in and captured Penny’s lips. Penny gave a content sigh. Sometimes it amazed her when Sheldon is the first to initiate anything remotely physical. Sheldon placed one hand on Penny’s cheek and the other rested comfortably on her knee. Penny uncrossed her legs and ran her fingers through Sheldon’s hair and deepened the kiss. Sheldon’s hand traveled slowly up Penny’s thigh.
Sheldon froze in his spot when his hand came in contact with something hard and smooth, with something that was definitely out of place. The shape and structure was familiar but it most certainly didn’t belong there.
Sitting back with wide eyes, Sheldon stared at Penny confusedly. Sheldon noted Penny’s mischievous grin and with cautious hands Sheldon untied her robe. Seeing what his hand discovered, Sheldon leaped from the bed in shock.
“PENNY! What...what are you wearing?”
“What does it look like?”
Penny stood, letting her robe fall and the explicit phallic appendage bounced with her every movement. Sheldon’s breath hitched as Penny advance towards him.
“It...ahhh...umm…looks…” Sheldon stammered.
“It’s a strap-on dildo.” Penny’s breath caressed Sheldon’s ear. “A dildo that I’m gonna fuck you with.” Penny pressed herself hotly against Sheldon.
“Penny…” Sheldon’s heart pounded in his chest. “Have you’ve lost your mind? What makes you think…”
“Its ok Sheldon don’t deny it. I know that you’re curious about this little…fetish.”
“I don’t know where you’ve obtain this information…” Sheldon desperately tried to put distance between himself and Penny. “…but I can assure you, you are mistaken…” Sheldon’s face twitched with every word.
“Uh-huh…so then answer this.” Penny grabbed Sheldon’s shirt. “Why does your face have more nervous ‘tics’ than a Lyme disease research facility?” Penny teasingly joked.
Sheldon blinked several times, trying to find a worthy response. Penny tiptoed and lightly kissed Sheldon’s lips.
“Do you trust me?” Penny gently caressed Sheldon’s cheek.
“Yes.”
“Then let me do this for you Sheldon. I want to be the one to do this.”
Sheldon grabbed Penny’s face, answering her question with a lust filled kiss. Frantically the two discarded Sheldon’s clothing.
Penny had Sheldon pinned to the bed, rubbing her “cock” against Sheldon’s painfully hard cock. The friction caused Penny to groan as the movement finally caused her internal plug to rub deliciously inside her.
Penny smiled devilishly at Sheldon before she licked down his chin, his neck, his chest, over his sensitive cock, stopping there to nudge Sheldon to flip onto all fours. Penny positioned herself and spread Sheldon’s ass cheeks apart. She stared at the inviting, little pucker before leaning in. Penny muffled a groan as she closed her eyes just as her tongue touched Sheldon’s opening.
Sheldon arched up as he felt Penny’s warm tongue against him.
"Oh, fuck…" he breathed out.
Penny circled the pucker before slipping the very tip of her tongue inside of him. After a few swipes of her tongue, Penny pulled away and sat up. Sheldon tilted his head back with pleading eyes.
“Suck them.”
Penny presented Sheldon with her fingers and he greedily took them in his mouth. His tongue danced up and down the sides of Penny’s slender fingers, bathing them erotically. Satisfied her fingers were properly lubed up, Penny placed her fingers at Sheldon’s entrance, sticking in one finger and moving it around slowly.
Sheldon gasped and bit down on Penny’s comforter.
By the time Penny eased the second finger into Sheldon’s body, he was writhing beautifully on the bed. His face glistening with sweat.
“Penny…” Sheldon chanted over and over again every time her finger brushed against his prostate.
Penny sensed Sheldon’s end was drawing near. With one last curl of her fingers, with Sheldon’s pleas bouncing off the walls through gritted teeth, Penny removed her fingers and sat back, staring lustfully at the obscene position Sheldon was in.
Looking back at Penny, Sheldon slowly scooted towards her with his legs wide apart, until the dildo was just brushing the outer rim of his hole.
“Are you ready sweetie?” Penny rubbed circles on Sheldon’s lower back.
“Yes…” Sheldon’s voice was low and throaty.
Penny's hands settled on Sheldon’s ass, pinching and kneading the flesh in silent appreciation. Sheldon held his breath when he felt himself being spread open. Slowly Penny pushed inside, allowing Sheldon time to adjust.
“Oh god.” Sheldon’s knuckles turned white from tightly gripping Penny’s bedding.
After a few moments, the pain turned to sheer pleasure.
“Move…please move…Penny…” Sheldon rocked his hips back into Penny.
Penny’s pace started out measured, not rushing it, wanting to make sure that Sheldon was all right. But soon after Sheldon’s little whimpers turned to full out groans and that fueled her on further, as she began to piston her hips harder into Sheldon.
“Oh god Sheldon.”
Penny threw her head back, the stimulation to her plug increased as her thrusts quicken.
“You’re so fucking hot like this…”
With one hand gripping Sheldon’s hip, the other trailed his back and woven into his short-cropped hair, pulling his head back forcefully, Penny thrust her hips erratically. With each thrust, Sheldon grunted unintelligible words.
Pulling his head back further, Penny kissed Sheldon, her tongue lapping furiously at the roof of his mouth, sucking on his tongue and tasting him in earnest.
“Faster…harder Penny…” Sheldon broke the kiss to beg.
Penny slowed her movements, almost pulling all the way out and painfully slow, thrusting back in.
“Penny PLEASE!!” Sheldon urged her with his hips.
“Please what?” Penny loved the whole role reversal. The power was heady.
“Uh…god…just…ummm….PLEASE!”
“Say it.” Penny stopped all movements completely.
“FUCK ME!”
That was all the encouragement Penny needed. She began to pound into Sheldon forcefully and he willingly took it, grinding back against her, driving her in deeper with each thrust.
Sheldon’s entire body began to shake. The pleasure that rocked him was nearly painful. He felt his arms tremble beneath him. There was just too much tension in his body and it all seemed to explode at once.
Penny watched as Sheldon’s eyes shot open, his mouth open in a silent scream. She slid her hand around his waist to pump his cock once, then twice as she gave one final hard thrust against his prostate before he let go cumming on her bed.
“PENNY!!!”
The sight, the sound of Sheldon and little pressure alone was enough to bring Penny over the edge.
Sheldon lost all support and laid motionlessly on the bed. The move caused Penny’s dildo to slip out. Penny stood from the bed and removed the strap-on. Crawling back onto the bed, Penny snuggled up to Sheldon’s side.
“How did you know…” Sheldon mumbled into the bed, not even trying to move.
“I just…I’ve got you pegged.” Penny smiled sweetly, kissing Sheldon’s shoulder.
Sheldon finally rolled onto his back, bringing Penny to rest against him, lying her head on his chest.
“I suppose you do.”
“Happy birthday Sheldon.”
“Thank you Penny.”