S10R11: Voting

Oct 02, 2009 22:38


Read more... )

voting

Leave a comment

Comments 12

coffee_scented October 3 2009, 10:08:37 UTC
ELIMINATIONS
#04 -- It's a little too heavy on the reds, the font is too moody for an icon like this and the composition is too median. I would suggest not cropping so close to the middle - the subject should usually occupy either 1/3 or 2/3 of the icon, not the half.

FAVOURITES
#03 -- Nice clear colors and good crop.

Reply


aye_seaturtle October 3 2009, 13:26:15 UTC
ELIMINATION
#04 -- The colouring on the houses is too vibrant and the text looks out of place.

FAVOURITE
#02 -- The muted colouring works well and the text compliments the icon.

Reply


holidaylights October 3 2009, 18:46:36 UTC
ELIMINATIONS
#05 -- Too much of the icon seems to be in the gray spectrum rather than black or white, and the green light texture at the bottomis distracting, and doesn't match the icon.

FAVOURITES
#02 -- Nice cropping and use of text.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

sidhex3 October 4 2009, 19:57:45 UTC
I need to you try to clarify where the icon is blurry and where it's oversharpened.

Reply


setentpet October 4 2009, 23:31:39 UTC
ELIMINATIONS
#04 -- The coloring is a little too saturated and the text is a little blrry.
FAVOURITES
#02 -- The text is great on this icon.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up