S10R12 ~ Voting

Oct 10, 2009 20:18


Read more... )

voting

Leave a comment

Comments 11

angelus2hot October 11 2009, 19:42:13 UTC
ELIMINATIONS
#03 -- The water is too green and bright, the bench color is too drab and the cropping brings part of the bench into focus instead of all of it.

FAVOURITES
#01 -- This icon has a peaceful tranquility to it. The coloring is subdued yet beautiful and the text gives just the right feel.

Reply


_jc_icons_ October 12 2009, 23:27:57 UTC
ELIMINATIONS
#02 -- Although the colors are beautiful, the sharpening gives the edges of the bench a ragged edge that I don't like.

FAVOURITES
#01 -- As well as making color adjustments, this icon maker has created a very strong feeling of nostalgia with the writing brush. It's a great icon.

Reply

setentpet October 13 2009, 20:30:10 UTC
Hi, thanks for your vote but can you reword your vote since phrases like "i don't like" are not allowed. Just explain a little more why you don't like it and it should be fine. Thanks so much!!

Reply

_jc_icons_ October 13 2009, 20:56:36 UTC
ELIMINATIONS
#02 -- Although the colors are beautiful, the sharpening gives the lines of the bench a ragged edge which makes it look a bit unfinished and contrasts too strongly with the soft background.

FAVOURITES
#01 -- As well as making color adjustments, this icon maker has created a very strong feeling of nostalgia with the writing brush. It's a great icon.

Reply


narniacmr October 13 2009, 14:28:34 UTC
ELIMINATIONS
#01 -- The texture overpowers the icon and its a bit dark.

FAVOURITES
#02 -- Beautiful coloring.

Reply


setentpet October 13 2009, 22:18:59 UTC
VOTING CLOSED

Reply


Leave a comment

Up