round02; challenge seven - results

[minqie]

Elimination
crystalplane(-3)(-4)SET A


People's Choicexinliyoushu (+2)elmasageng (+2) 


People's Choice
elmasageng(+2)(+1)SET C


No mod's choice on this challenge.

Tallies
1 ---
2 ----
3 ++
4 +
5 ++
6 -++
7 -+
8 ---

Set A
Set B +
Set C +++
Set D

Elimination comments
1 - a little faded, wish this had more color
1 - the texture and pic look fine, just the white light in the picture made it weird
1 - The icon is oversharpened and the picture is too washed out.
1 - the members appear too faded.
2 - The texture placement is great, but the image's color is bland and doesn't fit the icon.
2 - the subject is too dark, the texture is overpowering the subject of the icon
3 - it would be nice if the colors were a little more stronger
3 - The texture doesn't add to the appeal of the icon and is awkwardly placed around the subject.
4 - The icon is too dark and and the text is distracting and doesn't match icon.
4 - the blending between texture and picture fine, just the test bothered it.

Favourite comments
3 -
3 - nice coloring and cropping :)
4 - Love the colorings :D
5 - Lovely cropping and the fading white effect.
5 - The cropping, coloring, fade out are all gorgeous.
6 - The texture use is just wonderful, along with the cropping!!!
6 - Excellent use of textures.
7 - lovely coloring. i love how leeteuk's face is sharp but not his hand.

Favourite set:
Set B -
Set C -
Set C -
Set C - Both of the icons are lovely and very different.