WAR 01 BATTLE 04: RESULTS
Here are the results!
We only have one elimination this week.
with 8 points
BATTLE 04 CITIZENS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#02) // +7 points
* Comment to this post if you would like a banner.
BATTLE 04 GENERALS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#04)
redone: I think the shading on this icon is absolutely spectacular, although at parts, it's a bit oversharpened. Stil, great use of a crop which is everywhere, and I mean, everywhere (Almost all Hibarism fangirls have iconned it XD).
BATTLE 04 POINT GAIN/LOSS
+2 Points
1. Mitani Yuuki
+1 Point
2. Shuusuke Fuji
+0 Points
3. Kiba
-1 Point
4. C.C.
BATTLE 04 RESULTS TALLIES
1. -6, +1 = -5 points
2. +7 points
3. -3, +3 = 0 points
4. -2 points
Link to voting table.
Icons were given +1 battle points for a priority 1 fave vote, and -1 for a priority 1 negative vote. Icons were then ranked based on number of battle points and organized into ranking quartiles, then given war points or had war points taken away based on that ranking. If any part of that is unclear, please let me know.
If you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon and your avatar name. We will reply with a list of all the good/bad crits you received. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will email the crits to you. Note: Some of the crits were VERY harsh. Do not ask for your critiques unless you're sure you can handle it. All crits will be kept 100% anonymous.
We only have one elimination this week.
with 8 points
BATTLE 04 CITIZENS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#02) // +7 points
* Comment to this post if you would like a banner.
BATTLE 04 GENERALS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#04)
redone: I think the shading on this icon is absolutely spectacular, although at parts, it's a bit oversharpened. Stil, great use of a crop which is everywhere, and I mean, everywhere (Almost all Hibarism fangirls have iconned it XD).
BATTLE 04 POINT GAIN/LOSS
+2 Points
1. Mitani Yuuki
+1 Point
2. Shuusuke Fuji
+0 Points
3. Kiba
-1 Point
4. C.C.
BATTLE 04 RESULTS TALLIES
1. -6, +1 = -5 points
2. +7 points
3. -3, +3 = 0 points
4. -2 points
Link to voting table.
Icons were given +1 battle points for a priority 1 fave vote, and -1 for a priority 1 negative vote. Icons were then ranked based on number of battle points and organized into ranking quartiles, then given war points or had war points taken away based on that ranking. If any part of that is unclear, please let me know.
If you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon and your avatar name. We will reply with a list of all the good/bad crits you received. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will email the crits to you. Note: Some of the crits were VERY harsh. Do not ask for your critiques unless you're sure you can handle it. All crits will be kept 100% anonymous.