Comments | tenminjoe: Film catch-up

tenminjoe

Film catch-up

Jul 25, 2006 12:51

I got behind on these somehow, quick catch-up:

X-Men 3: Surprisingly good, largely because Ian McKellan carries it.

Thank You For Smoking: Pretty good, but not great. Funny, but not nearly as dark as I was hoping or as some reviewers seem to think it is.

The Island: Really, really stupid. An insult to my intelligence. And thus bad. Nice effects ( Read more... )

Comments 4

origamitiger July 25 2006, 18:51:24 UTC

We thought pirates was good fun.

tenminjoe July 25 2006, 18:53:29 UTC

It was good fun! I thought the first one was excellent, so when I say it's not as good as the first one, that's not really a harsh criticism. Looking forward to part 3 very much; I think that having a satisfying ending will make all the difference.

peachweeks July 25 2006, 18:57:48 UTC

Superman Returns was a turgid, wasted opportuninty, surely.

tenminjoe July 25 2006, 18:59:22 UTC

I honestly don't think I'm capable of making any kind of sensible critical judgement about Superman movies. I was excited by just the theme music.