Round 4 Challenge 2 results
Not as good a turnout as last week, but still thanks to everyone who voted!
VOTED OFF
by drunkardmuses
by kyrina
Thanks for your entries, I hope you stick around for future votings :)
PEOPLE'S CHOICE
by dana_cz
MOD'S CHOICE
by lorien_79
heh! :)
If you want a banner let me know in a comment. Banners will be made for people's choice and mod's choice, they might take a while though^^
the voting results:
01. -5
02. +3
03. +1
04. -1 +1 = 0
05. -4
06. -2 +1 = -1
find your icon number here
the reasons given for the votes:
01. negative: 5 | positive: 0
- text doesn't fit the image and the color seems off
- The yellow and the lime green are hard to read and are distracting.
- the image is a little washed out by all the greens and I'm not too sure what the text is about
- it's a bit dark and the greenish texture gives DT a slightly sickly colour (doesn't really fit the content of the given pic - in my opinion)
- The text is too bright and difficult to read and the background color doesn't look well with the image.
02. negative: 0 | positive: 3
+ So random that it gives completely different reasoning for the expression and actually manages to change it from carry on humour to serious pondering so I thought it was very clever.
+ Love the background!
+ nice crop
03. negative: 0 | positive: 1
+ great coloring, and fantastic text
04. negative: 1 | positive: 1
- Think it loses context a little with the crop though love the smilie!
+ The smiley along with the look on his face makes you smile and the way the original image is cut off is very nice.
05. negative: 4 | positive: 0
- Looks a little too pixelated and grainy, good composition and nice background idea though.
- the image is over-sharpened
- the face looks strange, as if tried too much to make it sharp and now it's kind of grainy
- The original image looks blurry and grainy and it just seems a little too plain.
06. negative: 2 | positive: 1
- coloring seems too bright, he looks a bit washed out
- Too bright. Most of the colors just seem to blend together, which makes it look washed out and hard to look at.
+ like the overall layout, the figure is nicely placed and the colour gives it a warm mood
please let me know if you notice any mistakes. Also, please tell me if you'd rather have longer reasons next time (i.e. I'll ask voters to provide more detailed reason if they're too short). I know some of these are pretty short, and if there's a majority here that prefers more details, we can do that ;)
I'll post the new challenge in a bit :)
VOTED OFF
by drunkardmuses
by kyrina
Thanks for your entries, I hope you stick around for future votings :)
PEOPLE'S CHOICE
by dana_cz
MOD'S CHOICE
by lorien_79
heh! :)
If you want a banner let me know in a comment. Banners will be made for people's choice and mod's choice, they might take a while though^^
the voting results:
01. -5
02. +3
03. +1
04. -1 +1 = 0
05. -4
06. -2 +1 = -1
find your icon number here
the reasons given for the votes:
01. negative: 5 | positive: 0
- text doesn't fit the image and the color seems off
- The yellow and the lime green are hard to read and are distracting.
- the image is a little washed out by all the greens and I'm not too sure what the text is about
- it's a bit dark and the greenish texture gives DT a slightly sickly colour (doesn't really fit the content of the given pic - in my opinion)
- The text is too bright and difficult to read and the background color doesn't look well with the image.
02. negative: 0 | positive: 3
+ So random that it gives completely different reasoning for the expression and actually manages to change it from carry on humour to serious pondering so I thought it was very clever.
+ Love the background!
+ nice crop
03. negative: 0 | positive: 1
+ great coloring, and fantastic text
04. negative: 1 | positive: 1
- Think it loses context a little with the crop though love the smilie!
+ The smiley along with the look on his face makes you smile and the way the original image is cut off is very nice.
05. negative: 4 | positive: 0
- Looks a little too pixelated and grainy, good composition and nice background idea though.
- the image is over-sharpened
- the face looks strange, as if tried too much to make it sharp and now it's kind of grainy
- The original image looks blurry and grainy and it just seems a little too plain.
06. negative: 2 | positive: 1
- coloring seems too bright, he looks a bit washed out
- Too bright. Most of the colors just seem to blend together, which makes it look washed out and hard to look at.
+ like the overall layout, the figure is nicely placed and the colour gives it a warm mood
please let me know if you notice any mistakes. Also, please tell me if you'd rather have longer reasons next time (i.e. I'll ask voters to provide more detailed reason if they're too short). I know some of these are pretty short, and if there's a majority here that prefers more details, we can do that ;)
I'll post the new challenge in a bit :)