round 0 challenge 3 results

Nov 25, 2007 06:23

thanks so much for voting everyone! :)


voting tally
01. 11 votes - 2nd place (sidhex3)
02. 06 votes - 3rd place (dragonflyopera)
03. 00 votes - 4th place (a_boleyn1230)
04. 13 votes - 1st place (overevery)

which leads to the following points total...

#usernamesp12345total
1
a_boleyn1230 0 7 4 4 - - 15
2
lady_boromir 0 0 0 0 - - 00 3
dragonflyopera 0 4 3 5 - - 12 4
tyniere 0 6 7 0 - - 13 5
overevery 0 3 0 7 - - 10 6
eviltera 0 0 5 0 - - 05 7
sidhex3 0 5 6 6 - - 17

If anybody wants a banner for this challenge, let me know in a comment :)

Comments (either given with the voting or extra)

icon #1
- good composition
- Background is simple yet elegant, works well with the text. The fonts are also a nice choice.
- the different fonts go so well together to really compliment the text and background texture/image.
- great text placement and texture

icon #2
- A good choice of base with eye-catching colours; the text is perhaps a little too large for the space but is very clear, and the type face fits the quote well.
- great font
- such pretty, subtle background colors, and the text is elegant and fitting. Gives a calm, soothing impression.

icon #3
- While this is a very nice icon (love the colours) I think the background is too cluttered here. It distracts from the text, and makes it hard to read in some places.

icon #4
- The type is interesting but, because the base is so simple, it would have been nice if the maker had varied it more -- perhaps to add emphasis to a particular word.
- Simple, the way a text icon should be. Nice font, easy to read. Background has just enough texture that it's not plain, but not so much that it's distracting.
- very simple and crisp, as a text icon should be. I like the muted background with the texture. Great font choice, unique and classy!

if you notice any mistakes please let me know!

eviltera will put the next challenge up soon^^

round 0, challenge 3, results

Previous post Next post
Up